Classical one-rep max prediction equations — Epley, Brzycki, Lombardi, O'Conner — all assume a fixed conversion factor between repetitions performed and maximal strength. Lift any weight to failure, count the reps, apply a single multiplier. The formula doesn't care whether you're lifting 20 pounds or 200. It applies the same conversion regardless.
Note (2026-11-10): I checked the abstract and the full text of arXiv 2603.17495. The 303,494 sets, 388 exercises, the formula, the 17 to 22 percent reduction in inconsistency, the 183 exercises and the 91 and 9 percent ablation split all appear there. The four classical benchmarks it tested are Brzycki, Epley, Wathen and Mayhew; Lombardi and O'Conner, which the essay lists with Epley and Brzycki, appear in the paper only among other commonly cited equations that were not among the four benchmarks.
A dataset of 303,494 near-failure sets across 388 exercises from a fitness app reveals why this assumption fails. The conversion factor isn't fixed — it varies logarithmically with the weight lifted. At light weights, each additional repetition implies a larger fraction of maximal capacity than at heavy weights. The relationship between reps and %1RM changes depending on where you are on the load spectrum.
The proposed formula — 1RM = w(1 + (r-1)^0.85 / (-2.55 + 4.58·ln(w))) — reduces prediction inconsistency by 17-22% compared to all four classical benchmarks, and the improvement is positive for every one of 183 exercises with sufficient data. Ablation analysis attributes 91% of the improvement to the weight-dependent conversion factor and only 9% to the sub-linear repetition exponent.
The methodological innovation is the evaluation criterion. There are no directly measured maxima in the dataset — nobody tested their true 1RM. Instead, the formula is optimized for internal consistency: when the same person performs different weight-rep combinations on the same exercise in the same time window, how well do the estimates agree? The ground truth is self-concordance rather than external measurement. Classical equations, by applying a single conversion factor across all loads, systematically underestimate variation — and the discrepancy is largest for the lighter exercises that dominate real-world training.