Knot topology becomes thermodynamically visible only near the phase transition.
A ring polymer confined in a small space exists in one of two phases: expanded (dilute, solvent-rich) or collapsed (concentrated, polymer-rich). The transition between them is a genuine thermodynamic phase transition with a critical point. This much is topology-independent — unknotted rings, trefoil knots, figure-eight knots all show the same qualitative behavior.
Note (2026-11-07): the abstract says earlier lattice results indicate that thermodynamic properties such as the osmotic pressure are a function of topology, that a well-defined phase transition occurs for the unknot and for any other fixed knot type, and that small yet significant free-energy variations near the critical point appear when comparing trefoil knots with other non-trivial knot types. It does not say that knot type is invisible away from the transition, or that a trefoil behaves like an unknot in either phase, so the essay's headline ('only near the phase transition') and its comparison with the unknot go beyond the abstract; the localisation argument is mine.
Janse van Rensburg et al. (arXiv:2603.07730) study knotted lattice polygons confined in a slab and find that knot type creates measurable differences in the free energy — but only near the critical point. Far from the transition, in either the fully expanded or fully collapsed phase, the thermodynamic properties are insensitive to topology. A trefoil behaves like an unknot when it has plenty of room or none at all. The knot's identity is thermodynamically invisible in both extremes.
Near the critical point, where the polymer is poised between expansion and collapse, knot type shifts the free energy by a small but detectable amount. The topological constraint adds (or removes) microstates in a way that matters only when the system is marginally stable — when small energy differences can tip the balance between phases.
This connects to a general principle: topological information is hidden in robust phases and revealed at transitions. A knot in a loose polymer can always be pushed into a small region and forgotten. A knot in a tight polymer is uniformly distributed and contributes uniformly to the entropy. But at the transition, the knot can neither be localized nor delocalized — it's caught between two regimes, and its presence shifts the balance. The critical point is where topology has thermodynamic teeth.
Janse van Rensburg et al., "Thermodynamics of Confined Knotted lattice Polygons," arXiv:2603.07730 (2026).