The age distribution of dengue, Zika, and chikungunya cases is remarkably consistent across different outbreak sizes, geographic regions, time periods, and population scales. Despite enormous variation in total case counts -- from small local outbreaks to national epidemics -- the proportion of cases in each age group holds steady. In contrast, infections transmitted by other vectors (malaria by Anopheles, leishmaniasis by sandflies) show distinctly different and less stable age patterns.
The authors conclude that for Aedes-transmitted diseases, the age distribution is determined primarily by the ecological interaction between the mosquito and its human hosts, not by the epidemiology of the pathogen itself. Three different viruses, with different immunological profiles and different clinical presentations, produce the same age curve because they share the same vector. The mosquito's biting preferences, activity patterns, and habitat overlap with different age groups imprint a signature on the case distribution that the pathogen cannot override.
Note (2026-11-11): checked against the paper's full text (this essay had been logged as held up on an abstract-level read). The comparison of Aedes-transmitted infections with malaria and leishmaniasis, and the paper's reading that the age distribution of cases is mainly due to the interaction between vectors and hosts, are as in the paper. Three things differ. (1) Scope: the paper analyzes officially reported cases in large and medium-size Brazilian urban centres and for Brazil as a whole, and states its conclusion 'in Brazil at least'; the essay speaks of different geographic regions without that limit. (2) Strength: the abstract says the age distribution is 'probably determined' by the ecological interactions; the essay says the authors conclude it is determined primarily by them and that the pathogen cannot override the vector's imprint. The paper also says that the burden of symptomatic disease may fall mainly on adults because a large fraction of the adult population is immunologically naive, and lists limitations: it uses officially reported counts and does not consider underreporting or the different dengue serotypes. (3) The essay's specific mechanism (the mosquito's biting preferences, activity patterns and habitat overlap, and mosquito behavior varying less than immune history) goes beyond the paper, which mentions biting habits, occupational behavior of hosts and housing conditions as influences on human-vector contact, and indoor versus outdoor biting as a possible further influence, and I did not find a test of them or a comparison of the stability of vector behavior with that of immune history.
This is a case where the delivery mechanism dominates the content. The virus determines what disease you get; the vector determines who gets it. And because the vector-host interaction is more stable than the virus-host interaction -- mosquito behavior varies less than immune history -- the age distribution becomes a fingerprint of the transmission route rather than the transmitted agent. In any system where the channel of delivery is shared across different payloads, the channel's properties may leave a stronger demographic imprint than the payload's properties.
(arXiv:2603.16773)