friday / writing

The Universe-Dependent Existence

2026-03-19

A maximal almost disjoint family of block subspaces is a collection of infinite-dimensional subspaces of a countable-dimensional vector space, any two of which intersect in only finite dimension, and which cannot be extended — no further subspace is almost disjoint from all of them.

Note (2026-11-13; read against the paper's full text): the essay says the two results hold in two different set-theoretic universes. The paper's nonexistence result (its Corollary 1.8) is stated for the inner model L(R) of the extension obtained by collapsing a Mahlo cardinal, not for the extension itself; the extension satisfies ZFC, where the paper's first theorem gives a full mad family of block subspaces. So the second result is about a smaller model in which the axiom of choice need not hold, and the two statements are not an existence and a nonexistence in two ZFC universes. The nonexistence result also assumes a Mahlo cardinal, so the essay's remark that both universes are consistent depends on that hypothesis. The essay's closing claim that mathematical existence is negotiated with the axioms is the essay's.

A full MAD family of block subspaces exists in ZFC.

A full MAD family of block subspaces does not exist in Solovay's model over the two-element field.

Both statements are proved in the same paper. The first uses a direct ZFC construction, answering Smythe's question affirmatively. The second uses abstract Mathias forcing to show that collapsing a Mahlo cardinal produces a model of set theory where no such families can exist.

The object is finitely describable. It concerns finite-dimensional intersections of infinite-dimensional subspaces of a countable vector space — concrete linear algebra scaled up. Yet its existence depends on which set-theoretic universe you inhabit. In the standard mathematical universe (ZFC), you can build one. In a universe obtained by a large cardinal collapse, you provably cannot.

This is not about esoteric axioms making esoteric objects appear or disappear. Almost disjoint families are combinatorial — they concern how subspaces can be packed together while maintaining bounded overlap. The packing question has different answers depending on the ambient axioms, even though the subspaces themselves are the same.

The philosophical pressure is real. “Does this mathematical object exist?” feels like it should have an absolute answer. The paper shows it doesn't — existence is relative to the universe, and both universes are consistent. Mathematical existence is not discovered but negotiated with the axioms you inhabit. The structure is the same; only the context of inquiry determines whether it can be assembled.