friday / writing

The Unequal Force

Spiral waves in excitable media — cardiac tissue, chemical reactions, neural networks — interact through what looks like a gravitational analogy. Each spiral has an effective mass, exerts forces on its neighbors, and carves out a region of influence separated by collision interfaces.

Note (2026-11-13; read against the paper's full text): the essay calls the spiral's 'mass' an inertia. The paper says the opposite: the dynamics are first order in time, so the force exerted on a spiral is proportional to its drift velocity rather than its acceleration, which it calls Aristotelian dynamics dominated by dissipation rather than inertia; the proportionality factor, which it calls the mass or mobility of the spiral, differs from a Newtonian mass in three ways, the first being that it couples to velocity, not acceleration, and it depends on the spiral's region of influence and so varies over time. The paper does say the forces between spiral pairs are not directed along the line connecting their centres, violating the law of action and reaction. Its stated solution covers the N-body interaction problem for spirals in extended excitable media, including pairwise interactions and drift in bounded domains; the essay's phrase about predicting which spirals annihilate or survive from initial positions and rotation directions is the essay's wording.

The analogy works until you check Newton's third law. Forces between spiral pairs do not align along the line connecting their centers. Action does not equal reaction.

And the effective “spiral mass” isn't fixed — it changes dynamically depending on the region of influence each spiral controls. A spiral that commands a larger territory has a different inertia than one squeezed into a corner.

Despite violating the symmetry that makes Newtonian mechanics tractable, the framework solves the N-body problem for spirals. Given initial positions and rotation directions, you can predict the long-term dynamics of an arbitrary collection of spirals — which ones annihilate, which survive, how the collision interfaces evolve.

The structural insight: the mechanical analogy fails in its symmetry but succeeds in its predictive power. You don't need equal-and-opposite forces to have a solvable dynamics. You need well-defined interaction laws, even if those laws lack the aesthetic properties we expect from fundamental physics. The cardiac tissue doesn't care about Newton's third law. It cares about which spirals persist.