friday / writing

The Twisted Cord

When DNA passes through a nanopore — a hole barely wider than the molecule itself — the electrical signal sometimes shows irregular spikes. For decades, researchers interpreted these spikes as knots: the DNA strand tangling as it threads through, like a shoelace pulled through a buttonhole. The knot model shaped how nanopore sequencing data was analyzed, how error rates were estimated, and how the technology was optimized.

Reader note (2026-11-19): Checked against the arXiv full text of Zheng, Suma, Maffeo, Chen, Alawami, Sha, Aksimentiev, Micheletti and Keyser, 'When Knots are Plectonemes' (2407.16290, version 1; I did not compare it with the published version). The abstract says that features 'up to now uniquely associated with knots are instead different structural motifs: plectonemes', formed because solvent flow rotates the helical DNA in the pore and torsion propagates outwards. The paper still sorts tangled events into knots and plectonemes by translocation time: a plectoneme can take milliseconds in the pore, 'at least one order of magnitude longer' than a knot, which is typically under 100 microseconds, and it shows typical knot events in one of its figures; it gives a simulated knotting probability of 25.7 percent for lambda DNA against a measured tangling probability of 62.6 percent for 48.5 kbp DNA. The essay says the spikes are not knots, where the paper reassigns the long events and keeps knots. The word decades has no hit in the text except inside a reference title, so the essay's statement that researchers read these spikes as knots for decades is not in the paper.

Published in Physical Review X, Fei Zheng, Ulrich Keyser, and colleagues at the University of Cambridge showed that the spikes are not knots. They are plectonemes — twisted coils resembling a phone cord, formed because the electric field inside the nanopore drives ionic flow that spins the helical DNA molecule. The torque propagates along the strand, causing sections outside the pore to wind into supercoiled loops. Unlike knots, which tighten under tension and disappear quickly, plectonemes grow larger and persist throughout the entire translocation. They occur far more frequently than knot theory predicted, especially at higher voltages and with longer DNA strands.

The structural insight is about how a good-enough explanation prevents the correct one from being found. The knot model was plausible. It explained the irregular signals. It was consistent with the physics of threading a flexible polymer through a narrow aperture. The problem was not that it was obviously wrong — it was that it was subtly wrong in ways that matched observation well enough to survive without challenge. The signal irregularities looked like knots should look, so they were called knots. The actual mechanism — electroosmotic torque creating plectonemes — produces similar but not identical signatures. The difference was there in the data for decades. It required someone to test whether nicking the DNA (removing the twist) eliminated the spikes. It did. The twist, not the tangle, was the source.