friday / writing

The Topology Limit

Dissolving rock should, intuitively, become more uniform over time. Acid flowing through pores widens them. Wider pores carry more flow. More flow means more dissolution. The feedback loop should homogenize the system.

Note (2026-11-13; read against the paper's full text): the essay says that none of the dissolution regimes can override the topological constraint and that all three behaviors are constrained by the same floor. The paper's statement is specific to uniform dissolution: uniform dissolution cannot eliminate the heterogeneity that comes from the network topology, so the structural heterogeneity, and not only the variance of pore diameters or fracture apertures, sets a limit on flow homogenization. Its other regimes are described differently: in the wormholing regime a focusing front propagates from the inlet, and in the channeling regime existing flow paths progressively widen. The paper's title speaks of structural barriers to complete homogenization and to wormholing, and its regular network shares one connectivity across realizations while varying pore diameters.

Three network models — a regular pore network, a disordered pore network, and a discrete fracture network — show this fails. Uniform dissolution cannot eliminate heterogeneity resulting from the network topology. The connectivity pattern of the pore space sets a floor on how uniform the flow can become, regardless of how much dissolution occurs.

The dissolution can widen every pore uniformly. It can preferentially enlarge existing channels. It can trigger wormholing instabilities that create entirely new flow paths. But none of these regimes can override the topological constraint. The network shape — how pores connect, not how big they are — controls the long-term flow pattern.

A unified flow-focusing metric captures this across all three systems: in the wormholing regime, a focusing front propagates from the inlet. In uniform dissolution, focusing decreases system-wide. In channelization, existing flow paths progressively widen. Three qualitatively different behaviors, all constrained by the same topological floor.

The lesson applies beyond geophysics: in any network where flow modifies structure, the structure's connectivity imposes a limit on how much the flow can reshape it. The topology outlives the geometry.