Neptune's spin axis is tilted 28 degrees from its orbital plane. The standard explanation is a giant impact — some massive collision in the early solar system knocked it sideways. Gomes shows that Triton alone could have done it, gently, over billions of years.
Triton orbits Neptune retrograde — the only large moon in the solar system to do so. It was almost certainly captured, not formed in place. As tidal dissipation gradually shrank Triton's orbit, the changing orbital dynamics coupled to Neptune's spin through resonance. The spin axis tracked the resonance, tilting slowly but persistently.
Note (2026-11-11): checked against the paper (single author, Rodney Gomes) through its abstract and the passages of its text I searched. The mechanism (a spin-axis resonance with the solar system eigenfrequency s8, driven by the tidal evolution of a captured Triton-mass satellite) and the integration of the equations for 4.5 billion years are as in the paper. Four statements go further. (1) The essay says that Triton alone could have done it. The paper's conclusion is conditional, that if Neptune initially had a near-zero obliquity its current value could have been naturally engendered by Triton's tidal evolution (the title says 'was likely engendered'); the resonance is with a solar system frequency, and the simulations include the Sun and the other three giant planets. Obliquities above 20 degrees arise in roughly a third of the cases, and increases beyond 50 degrees in some. (2) The essay says the mechanism is observable today, that Triton's orbit is still decaying and dissipating, and that the mechanism is still operating. I found no such statement: the paper's simulations start from a newly captured satellite and count as successes those that end near Triton's present, nearly circular orbit. (3) The essay says the giant impact hypothesis is an explanatory habit preferred because the template existed. The abstract says the embryo-collision scenario has the advantage of naturally explaining the large axial tilts of the ice giants and offers Triton's tides as an alternative that avoids late-stage catastrophic collisions. (4) That the tidal mechanism is more testable than a collision is the essay's own argument.
No catastrophe required. No impactor that conveniently disappeared. Just a captured moon, tidal friction, and time. The 28-degree tilt emerges from the same mechanism that is observable today — Triton's orbit is still evolving, still dissipating.
What this replaces is revealing. The giant impact hypothesis for obliquities is an explanatory habit — it works for Uranus (97-degree tilt), so it gets applied everywhere. But Neptune's tilt is moderate enough that tidal evolution can produce it without invoking an unseen impactor. The more dramatic explanation (collision) was preferred not because the evidence demanded it but because the template existed.
The structural point: when a gentle, ongoing process can produce the same outcome as a violent, instantaneous one, the ongoing process has the advantage of being testable. Triton is still there. Its orbit is still decaying. The mechanism is still operating.