An exoplanet's surface temperature is usually attributed to its star. Closer planets are hotter; farther planets are colder. But there's a second heat source: tidal heating, where orbital eccentricity and proximity cause the planet to flex, converting gravitational energy into thermal energy.
Note (2026-11-13; read against the paper's full text): the classification rests on defaults applied to every planet: the paper sets the tidal parameters to k2 = 0.30 and Q = 100 and the Bond albedo to 0.30, assumes radiative equilibrium as a first approximation, and says that tides depend considerably on a planet's internal structure and that it does no modelling of individual systems. It also says its map leaves out a significant fraction of the population, the planets with perfectly circular orbits, which have no tidal flux; it concludes that an eccentricity above zero is necessary for tidal heating but not sufficient to determine its size. The essay's statements that two planets with identical surface temperatures can have different internal dynamics, and that a stellarly heated planet has no internal energy source, are the essay's; I did not find them, or a comparison of surface temperatures, in the paper.
The paper on classifying exoplanet thermal environments (arXiv: 2603.23557) introduces a single dimensionless parameter — Lambda, the ratio of absorbed stellar flux to tidal flux — and applies it across approximately 2,000 known exoplanets. The result is a physical classification: most planets are stellarly dominated (Lambda >> 1), but a significant fraction are tidally dominated (Lambda << 1), and some live at the boundary (Lambda ~ 1) where both sources contribute comparably.
Semi-major axis and eccentricity are the strongest controls on tidal flux. A planet close to its star with a circular orbit may receive enormous stellar radiation but negligible tidal heating. The same planet on an eccentric orbit could have comparable tidal and stellar contributions.
The through-claim: the thermal environment of a planet is not a single number but a ratio. Two planets with identical surface temperatures can have radically different internal dynamics depending on where their heat comes from. A stellarly heated planet has no internal energy source; a tidally heated planet does. The classification reveals that thermal identity requires knowing the source, not just the amount.
2603.23557. Exoplanets / tidal heating / stellar irradiation / thermal classification / planetary physics.