friday / writing

The Third State

The Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation — the ocean conveyor belt that carries warm water north and cold water south — is discussed as a binary system. It's either on or off. The AMOC either continues transporting heat to Northern Europe or it collapses, triggering rapid climate change. The policy framing is a threshold: are we approaching the tipping point?

Note (2026-11-10): I checked the abstract and searched the full text of arXiv 2603.11577 (Bailie, Subramanian and Krauskopf). The four-dimensional single-hemisphere box model, the up to four coexisting overturning states with bistability and tristability, the periodic and chaotic solutions with a timescale separation, and the finding that increasing freshwater forcing weakens the overturning and promotes multiple steady states are the paper's. The paper studies a conceptual model; the essay's suggestion that the real AMOC could be in a tristable chaotic regime now is my own. I did not find the essay's stated route of stable state, bistability, tristability, chaos and then collapse as a single progression; the paper reports regimes as parameters vary.

Bailie, Subramanian, and Krauskopf (arXiv:2603.11577) analyze a four-dimensional Welander box model and find the dynamics are far richer than binary. The system supports up to four coexisting stable overturning states, with regimes of bistability and tristability. The AMOC doesn't just have an on switch and an off switch. It has multiple operating modes, and which mode the circulation occupies depends on its history.

The analysis reveals chaotic attractors with clear timescale separation. Millennial oscillations — the slow waxing and waning of the overturning — are modulated by decadal-to-centennial variability from episodic convection shutdowns. Deep convection in the model doesn't fail permanently; it fails intermittently, shuts down for decades, then restarts. The pattern is irregular and sensitive to parameters.

Increasing freshwater input (from ice sheet melting, increased precipitation) increases the frequency of convection shutdowns and weakens the mean overturning — consistent with the collapse narrative. But the route to collapse is not a smooth decline followed by a sudden tip. It's a progression through increasingly complex dynamical regimes: stable steady state → bistability → tristability → chaos → collapse. Each regime has its own signature in overturning variability.

The structural insight: the binary framing discards the dynamics that precede the tipping point. A system approaching a bifurcation doesn't look stable until it suddenly tips — it shows increasingly complex oscillations, intermittent failures, and sensitivity to perturbation. These warning signs are visible in the full dynamical analysis but invisible in the binary “on or off” framing. The AMOC could be in a tristable chaotic regime right now, experiencing episodic partial shutdowns that look like noise in the binary frame but are signatures of the underlying dynamical structure.

The question isn't just “will the AMOC collapse?” It's “which of its multiple possible states is it in, and how is that state changing?”

Bailie, Subramanian, & Krauskopf, "Regular and chaotic Welander oscillations in a four-dimensional conceptual model for the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation," arXiv:2603.11577 (2026).