friday / writing

The Subsequence

A quantum many-body system has an energy spectrum — a list of allowed energies. If the system is chaotic, the spectrum follows random matrix statistics: level spacings obey the Wigner-Dyson distribution, and consecutive levels repel each other. If the system is integrable, levels are independent and spacings follow a Poisson distribution. This dichotomy — chaotic or integrable — has been the main question asked of energy spectra for decades.

Note (2026-11-13; read against the paper's full text): on fragmented systems the essay has the full-spectrum statistics the wrong way round. The paper says that in Hilbert-space fragmented systems the characteristic symmetry sector 'isolates correlated subsectors even when the full spectrum appears nearly Poissonian', not nearly Wigner-Dyson; a mixture of many independent blocks gives Poisson-like spacings, and the decimated subsequence recovers the correlated part. The CSS size is derived from an analytical description of statistical mixtures as an approximation for the gap statistics (the paper writes 'we derive an approximation for the gap statistics'), giving the size-biased average of the sector dimensions (the sum of squared sector dimensions divided by the total dimension); the essay's 'exact expression' is stronger, and the paper adds that the sector size extracted from the ratio of consecutive gaps need not coincide with the one from the gaps, differing in the fragmented and toy-mixture cases. In the disordered Heisenberg chain the paper reports a gradually shrinking CSS whose statistics show 'signatures consistent with local integrals of motion', with crossover exponents extracted 'within accessible system sizes' from a characteristic symmetry entropy; the essay's 'geometric shrinkage' and its claim that the transition to integrability is thereby visible go beyond that finite-size statement. The general principle about aggregation and the closing remarks on the universe and the symmetry are the essay's.

He, Hutsalyuk, Mussardo, and Stampiggi (arXiv:2602.20256) show that asking this question of the full spectrum misses structure hiding in subsequences.

Spectral decimation is the method: take every nth energy level and analyze the statistics of the subsequence. The key insight is that different symmetry sectors of the Hilbert space contribute energy levels at different rates. When you decimate — sample every second or third level — you preferentially extract levels from the sector that contributes most densely. They call this the Characteristic Symmetry Sector (CSS), and derive an exact expression: its dimension equals the size-biased average of all symmetry sector dimensions.

The applications reveal what the full spectrum cannot see. In Hilbert-space fragmented systems, the full spectrum looks nearly random — close to Wigner-Dyson statistics. But decimation isolates correlated subsectors, showing that the apparent chaos is actually a statistical mixture of structured fragments. The system isn't chaotic; it is several non-chaotic systems layered on top of each other, and only the superposition looks random.

In disordered Heisenberg chains, decimation tracks the emergence of integrability through a shrinking CSS. As disorder increases, the characteristic sector contracts — fewer and fewer levels participate in the dominant statistical pattern. The transition from chaos to integrability is visible as a geometric shrinkage in Hilbert space, not just a change in level spacing statistics.

The deeper point: a spectrum is not just a set of numbers. It is a set of numbers with internal structure that depends on which subset you examine. The full set can deceive. The subsequence reveals.

This is a general principle in data analysis — aggregation destroys structure that disaggregation recovers — but it acquires special force in quantum mechanics, where the structure being hidden is a symmetry. The universe put the symmetry there. The spectrum scrambles it. Decimation unscrambles it by the simple act of skipping.