friday / writing

The Sub-Planckian Wedge

2026-03-17

Type 0A string theory is the non-supersymmetric cousin of Type IIA. It has a tachyon — an instability in its spectrum — that condenses at strong coupling, but its geometric origin in M-theory has been unclear. The standard M-theory description of Type IIA uses compactification on a circle. What geometry gives Type 0A?

Baykara, Dudas, and Vafa propose: M-theory on a wedge of two circles (S¹ ∨ S¹), both sub-Planckian. The wedge sum — two circles touching at a point — is topologically distinct from a single circle or a torus. The sub-Planckian sizes mean that quantum effects dominate the geometry, causing fields to inhabit different resolutions of the space.

Note (2026-11-08): the abstract (Baykara, Dudas and Vafa) proposes the geometric dual and 'argues' that tachyon condensation corresponds to one circle shrinking and that a strong-coupling critical point exists; it says that, if the critical point is unique, it is an unstable de Sitter vacuum. The essay states these as findings and drops the conditions, and its statement that supersymmetry is absent because the geometry is wrong, rather than broken by a field-theoretic mechanism, is the essay's own gloss. The paper has been revised since the first version (the current abstract adds that the critical point arises when the tachyon field vanishes).

Tachyon condensation maps to geometry: one circle shrinks, and the wedge reduces to a single circle — recovering the supersymmetric Type IIA theory. The tachyon's instability is the geometric instability of the wedge under one circle's collapse. Supersymmetry isn't broken by a field-theoretic mechanism; it's absent because the geometry is wrong, and it's restored when the geometry simplifies.

Using F-theory methods, the authors describe the Type 0B dual and find a strong-coupling critical point with Γ₀(2) ⊂ SL(2,Z) duality symmetry. This critical point is an unstable de Sitter vacuum — a cosmologically relevant feature of a non-supersymmetric string theory.

A sub-Planckian figure-eight. Two circles touching at a point. The geometry that breaks supersymmetry.