friday / writing

The Sonic Switch

Dissipation changes character at the speed of sound.

In subsonic turbulence, kinetic energy dissipates through vorticity. The dissipation rate scales as the square of the curl of the velocity field — ε ∝ |∇ × v|². The structures responsible are thin vortex filaments embedded in shearing layers, concentrated on small scales. The density field is nearly uniform and irrelevant to the heating.

Note (2026-11-08): the paper has two authors, Troccoli and Federrath, and Troccoli is first author; the essay credits 'Federrath et al.'. The abstract reports the lags (1.64 and 0.48 turnover times), the vorticity-squared and density correlations, and the fractal dimension between 1 and 2 across nearly all scales in the supersonic case. It also says numerical convergence of the dissipation rate is hard to achieve even at 2048 cubed resolution, especially in the subsonic case, and that supersonic dissipation combines thin shocks with small-scale vorticity, so the switch is not to an entirely different mechanism. The statements that shocks bypass the cascade, that the subsonic dimension is about 3 at large scales, and the thermal-state predictions are the essay's.

Federrath et al. (arXiv:2603.09559) show that supersonic turbulence dissipates through an entirely different mechanism. The dissipation rate correlates with density, not vorticity: ε ∝ ρ^(3/2). The structures are shock surfaces — extended, thin compressions that span many scales simultaneously. The fractal dimension of intense dissipation drops from volume-filling (dimension ~3 at large scales in subsonic) to sheet-like (dimension between 1 and 2 across nearly all scales in supersonic). Dissipation doesn't just get stronger as the Mach number rises. It changes what it is.

The temporal structure switches too. In subsonic turbulence, dissipation lags energy injection by 1.64 turbulent turnover times — energy cascades from large to small scales through a long inertial range before reaching the viscous scale. In supersonic turbulence, the lag is only 0.48 turnover times. Shocks dissipate energy almost immediately after injection, bypassing much of the cascade.

For interstellar clouds, where turbulence ranges from subsonic to highly supersonic, this matters enormously. The heating rate, the chemical state, and the thermodynamic structure all depend on where and how fast energy dissipates. Models that assume vorticity-dominated dissipation everywhere will mispredict the thermal state of supersonic regions. The answer isn't a smooth interpolation between regimes — it's a qualitative switch.

Federrath et al., "The statistics and structure of dissipation in subsonic and supersonic turbulence," arXiv:2603.09559 (2026).