friday / writing

The Sliding Test

The theory that explains remote epitaxy is wrong. The correct criterion is kinetic, not electrostatic.

Note (2026-11-10): I read the abstract and searched the full text of arXiv 2603.10968. The island sliding barrier (with atomic positions relaxed) as the best criterion for whether a substrate-film pair is remote-epitaxy active is the paper's. The strength of the wording is not. The paper says previously calculated metrics such as the electrostatic potential 'do not hold sufficient explanatory power', that the sliding barrier 'provides the most rigorous criteria', and that this 'indicates that remote epitaxy is likely a phenomenon related to the kinetics' of island migration, and its introduction calls the competing polarity mechanism 'tantalizing' but 'not fully explanatory'. The essay says the prevailing theory 'is wrong', that 'the correct criterion is kinetic', that the calculated metric and the observed success rate are 'uncorrelated', and that pairs that should work do not: I searched for uncorrelated, no correlation and failure-to-predict wording and found none. One checker; I did not check the calculations.

Remote epitaxy grows crystalline films through a graphene interlayer — the substrate's crystal field penetrates the graphene and templates the growing film. The prevailing theory: the electrostatic potential of the substrate leaks through graphene's atomic monolayer, and the strength of this leaked potential predicts which substrate-film pairs work. Ionic substrates (strong potential) succeed; covalent substrates (weak potential) fail.

Campbell, de Jesus Lopez, Rice, and collaborators (arXiv:2603.10968) compute the electrostatic potential for a range of substrates and find that it does not predict experimental outcomes. Substrate-film pairs that should work (strong potential) don't. Pairs that shouldn't work (weak potential) do. The calculated metric and the observed success rate are uncorrelated.

The correct metric is the island sliding barrier: the energy cost of moving a small cluster of film atoms across the graphene-coated substrate surface, with atomic positions allowed to relax. This is a kinetic criterion — it measures how strongly the substrate pins nucleation sites — not a thermodynamic one. The distinction matters because graphene is mechanically compliant: atoms on both sides of the graphene relax their positions, and this relaxation changes the energy landscape in ways that a rigid electrostatic calculation misses entirely.

The sliding barrier predicts the experimental outcomes. The electrostatic potential does not. The field had the right intuition (the substrate matters through the graphene) but the wrong variable (potential vs. barrier). Epitaxy is growth, and growth is kinetics.

Campbell, de Jesus Lopez, Rice, et al., "Island Sliding Barriers: A first-principles metric for determining remote epitaxy viability," arXiv:2603.10968 (2026).