Galaxy rotation curves don't match Newtonian gravity. Stars at the edge of a galaxy orbit faster than the visible mass can explain. The standard fix is dark matter — an invisible mass halo that supplies the missing gravity. The alternative fix is MOND — a modification of gravity itself at low accelerations. Both approaches work. Both require multiple free parameters per galaxy. Both carry theoretical commitments that extend far beyond the data they explain.
A February 2026 model fits all 175 galaxies in the SPARC database — the standard benchmark for rotation curves — with a single free parameter. Not one parameter per galaxy. One parameter total. The model uses only luminous mass estimates and standard relativistic principles, with no dark matter halo and no modification of gravity's force law.
Reader note (2026-11-17): The source line gives no identifier; the paper is arXiv:2602.24211, 'Single Parameter Model for Galaxy Rotation Curves' by Cisneros, Ott, Crowley, Roberts and Paz (February 2026). Checked against the full text. The model, the 175 SPARC galaxies and the comparison with dark matter match: an average reduced chi-squared of 2.24 against 4.19 for the Navarro-Frenk-White model on the same data, with more galaxies successfully fit. The essay says the model has one free parameter in total, not one per galaxy. The paper says there is one alpha value per galaxy: alpha is fitted for each galaxy (the fit is repeated from several starting values and the best kept), and its stated comparison is one free parameter per galaxy against at least two in the NFW and Einasto models. Its section on the number of free parameters says it presents the model as a single-parameter framework while disregarding the mass-to-light ratio parameters for the stellar disk and bulge, which the fit also yields. The paper reports a power-law relation between the fitted alpha and the ratio of total luminosity to half-light radius, which it says may remove the need for the free parameter, and it describes the dark matter contribution as encoded in two transformation terms of the luminous mass; the model also uses a choice of Milky Way luminous mass model as a fixed input.
The structural question this raises is about the relationship between fit quality and explanation. A model with one free parameter that fits 175 galaxies is parsimonious in a way that neither dark matter (which requires a halo profile per galaxy) nor MOND (which requires fine-tuning of the acceleration scale) can match. But parsimony is not truth. The single parameter might capture a deep physical principle, or it might be a well-constructed effective description that happens to span the data without touching the mechanism.
The through-claim: the number of free parameters is a measure of how much the model knows, but it is not a measure of what the model understands. A model with one parameter that fits everything has either discovered the correct generating principle or has found a mathematical surface that approximates the data without sharing its structure. The fit cannot distinguish these cases. The data are the same. The curves are the same. Only the physical story differs — and the story isn't in the data; it's in what the parameter means.
The galaxy rotation problem is not a shortage of models that fit. It is a surplus. The single dial adds one more fitting model to a field that has too many.