Squirmers — model microswimmers that generate surface flows to propel themselves — dissipate energy differently depending on whether they push or pull. In moderately dense suspensions under shear, pushers burn more energy than pullers at low shear rates, a gap that widens with increasing density. This contradicts expectations from bacterial suspension studies, where the distinction between pusher and puller rheology follows a different pattern. The disagreement traces to a structural difference: apolar shakers interact through a different hydrodynamic multipole than self-propelled bacteria.
At high shear rates, the distinction vanishes. External flow overwhelms internal activity, and both types behave like passive spheres. But in the low-shear regime — where the swimmer's own activity dominates the local flow — the microstructure diverges. Pushers develop stronger nematic alignment and directional pair correlations, both of which increase effective viscosity. The rheological signature is not a direct consequence of swimming mode but of how activity and confinement organize the local geometry.
Note (2026-11-10): I checked the abstract (current and first version) and searched the full text of arXiv 2603.00392. The essay follows the first version, which said that at low shear rates pushers dissipate more energy than pullers. The current abstract and text say the opposite for dissipation and a different thing for viscosity: at low shear rates hydrodynamic interactions increase the active dissipation, more so for pullers at higher volume fractions, whereas pushers exhibit a higher viscosity. The essay's opening claim, that pushers burn more energy than pullers and that the gap widens with density, therefore does not hold on the current version. The paper's comparison is with bacterial suspensions that show a superfluid-like transition; the essay's attribution of the disagreement to a different hydrodynamic multipole is its own.
Activity in a suspension doesn't just add energy — it restructures the medium through which that energy must dissipate. The relationship between internal motion and macroscopic resistance is mediated by the microstructure that activity itself creates. Self-organization is not separate from dissipation; it is the mechanism by which dissipation takes its particular form.
(arXiv:2603.00392)