Author note (2026-11-02). The paper cited here, arXiv:2603.10208 (“Unexpectedly Weak General Relativistic Effects in Strongly Relativistic Tidal Disruption Events”), is by Ho-Sang Chan, Taeho Ryu, Julian Krolik, Tsvi Piran. The name(s) this essay attributes it to (Andalman) do not appear among the listed authors, so the attribution below is wrong or refers to someone else's earlier work; I have not worked out which. Found by a mechanical check of each essay's named authors against the arXiv author list.
The debris should circularize quickly. It doesn't.
When a star passes close enough to a supermassive black hole, tidal forces tear it apart. The resulting debris stream follows highly eccentric orbits, and the standard expectation for strongly relativistic encounters — where the pericenter is only a few gravitational radii — is that relativistic apsidal precession will drive powerful shocks where the debris stream crosses itself. These shocks dissipate orbital energy rapidly, circularizing the debris into a compact accretion disk within days.
Andalman et al. (arXiv:2603.10208) simulate strongly relativistic tidal disruption events and find the opposite. The debris remains highly eccentric. The disk stays extended. The circularization that strong general relativity was supposed to accelerate doesn't happen on the expected timescale.
The mechanism is a self-defeating feedback loop. Relativistic precession does initially produce strong shocks at the stream self-intersection point. These shocks do dissipate energy — efficiently, for about a week. But the dissipation redistributes angular momentum in a specific way: it increases the angular momentum of the incoming stream. Higher angular momentum means a wider pericenter. A wider pericenter means weaker precession. Weaker precession means weaker shocks. Weaker shocks mean less dissipation. The relativistic effect dismantles its own engine.
The result: strongly relativistic TDEs look remarkably similar to weakly relativistic ones. The initial burst of relativistic activity quickly erases the conditions that made it possible. The system converges to the same extended, slowly evolving state regardless of how extreme the initial encounter was.
This is a general pattern: when a process modifies the conditions that enable it, the modification is self-limiting. Strong effects create their own attenuation. The interesting question is not the strength of the initial effect but the timescale over which self-regulation takes over — here, about one week.
Andalman et al., "Unexpectedly Weak General Relativistic Effects in Strongly Relativistic Tidal Disruption Events," arXiv:2603.10208 (2026).