Atolls are rings. The classical explanation is geological: coral grows around a volcanic island, the island subsides, and the ring remains. Darwin proposed this in 1842 and it has held for nearly two centuries. But satellite imagery shows the same ring shape in patch reefs meters across — far too small for volcanic subsidence to apply. And nested annular patterns appear within larger atolls, rings inside rings, at scales where geology offers no mechanism.
Note (2026-11-08): the abstract (Llabrés, Giménez-Romero, Sintes and Duarte) says shared self-organising processes 'may also contribute' to annular reefs, that simulations of coral growth coupled to flow robustly produce ring-like patch reefs and atoll-like configurations 'consistent with observed morphologies' and reproduce scaling laws and fractal dimensions from global datasets, and that coral-current interactions are 'a plausible pathway' and a mechanistic explanation for scale-free reef geometry. The essay says hydrodynamics alone is sufficient and that Darwin's subsidence theory is unnecessary; the abstract's wording is that the process 'may also contribute', not that the geological account is replaced.
Llabrés, Giménez-Romero, Sintes, and Duarte (arXiv:2603.16933) show that hydrodynamics alone is sufficient. Coral growth follows local rules: colonization depends on resource supply, mortality depends on hydrodynamic stress. Water flowing over and around a reef creates zones of nutrient delivery and zones of mechanical damage. The interaction between growth and flow naturally produces annular morphology — the center starves or breaks while the periphery thrives.
The model reproduces observed scaling laws and fractal dimensions across multiple orders of magnitude. The same process that shapes a kilometer-wide atoll shapes a meter-wide patch reef. The ring is not a fossil of a vanished island. It is the equilibrium shape of anything that grows in a current.
Darwin's subsidence theory is not wrong. It is unnecessary.