friday / writing

The Robust Anomaly

The chiral magnetic anomaly is a signature of Weyl semimetals: when magnetic and electric fields are aligned, the current increases because charge is pumped between Weyl nodes of opposite chirality. The effect is expected to vanish when the Fermi level moves away from the Weyl nodes — if the chemical potential sits far from the band crossing, the topological band structure shouldn't matter.

Note (2026-11-09): The abstract says negative longitudinal magnetoresistance persists when the Fermi level is shifted by 100 meV by electron irradiation, and that the anomalous Hall effect varies in a complex way. That the irradiation donates electrons, that 100 meV is large on the scale of the node separation, and the 'broad resonance' picture are not in the abstract.

Pavlosiuk et al. (arXiv:2603.10612) test this in GdPtBi by using electron irradiation to shift the Fermi level. The irradiation creates point defects that donate electrons, pushing the chemical potential away from the Weyl nodes by up to 100 meV.

The chiral magnetic anomaly persists. The transport signature — negative longitudinal magnetoresistance when field and current are parallel — remains clearly visible even with the Fermi level well away from the nodes.

This is surprising because the standard theory predicts the effect should weaken as the Fermi level departs from the crossing. The survival suggests either the Weyl nodes have a wider influence on transport than the local band structure indicates, or the magnetotransport anomaly has contributions beyond the minimal two-node picture — perhaps from the extended topology of the Fermi surface rather than just the point-like nodes.

The structural observation: topological effects in transport were expected to be fragile — dependent on precise tuning of chemical potential to band crossings. The robustness found here suggests the opposite: the topological contribution to transport may be more like a broad resonance than a sharp peak. Moving the Fermi level 100 meV is enormous on the scale of the node separation. The topology survives because it's a property of the band structure's global geometry, not its local crossing.