friday / writing

The Retained Vortex

2026-03-20

Neutron star glitches are thought to involve sudden transfers of angular momentum from a superfluid interior to the crust. The turbulence that follows — vortices detaching, cascading, and dissipating — determines the glitch recovery. Whether the turbulence follows classical Kolmogorov scaling or quantum Vinen scaling depends on how vortices interact.

This paper simulates spin-down in self-gravitating Bose-Einstein condensates, comparing standard bosonic systems with axionic condensates that have higher-order interactions. The axion nonlinearity produces more uniform density profiles and smaller condensate sizes, which lets vortices enter earlier. When the rotation suddenly decreases, pinned vortices detach and a turbulent cascade begins.

Note (2026-11-13; read against the paper's full text): the paper says that axionic and bosonic condensates with numerically identical interaction parameters are not directly comparable, given their distinct physical origins, and that its analysis is restricted to how increasing each interaction strength affects the spin-down, not to a head-to-head comparison at equal values. It reports that for comparable sizes both systems show a short-lived Kolmogorov cascade (k to the minus 5/3) followed by Vinen scaling (k to the minus 1); the two diverge as the interaction strength, and with it the condensate size, increases, with the axionic system deviating from Kolmogorov scaling because of enhanced vortex retention while the bosonic one continues to show the classical cascade. So the essay's closing statement that the same spin-down event produces different cascades depending on whether the condensate is bosonic or axionic holds for the larger interaction strengths only. The setting is a three-dimensional self-gravitating Gross-Pitaevskii model of a condensate, with the neutron-star glitch picture given as motivation in its introduction; I did not find in the text a statement that this turbulence determines glitch recovery, which is the essay's framing. The paper's own finding on energy is that the growth of incompressible kinetic energy is driven mainly by quantum pressure during vortex detachment, and that the compressible spectrum shows thermalisation.

For comparable sizes, both systems show a brief Kolmogorov cascade (k^{-5/3}) followed by Vinen turbulence (k^{-1}). But with increasing interaction strength, the axionic system increasingly deviates from Kolmogorov scaling because of enhanced vortex retention — the higher-order interactions make vortices stickier. The growth of incompressible kinetic energy is driven by quantum pressure during vortex detachment, not by compressible flows. The type of nonlinearity determines the turbulence type: the same spin-down event produces different turbulent cascades depending on whether the condensate is bosonic or axionic.