The Meissner effect is the definition of superconductivity. A superconductor expels magnetic flux from its interior — currents circulate on the surface and cancel the applied field inside. This diamagnetic response is not a secondary feature. It is the test. If a material shows the Meissner effect, it is a superconductor. If it doesn't, it isn't.
Note (2026-11-11): checked against the paper's full text. The measurements are reported correctly (the diamagnetic response screens about 100 ppm of the applied field in a few-micron sample; superconductivity onsets in the midst of a continuous transition to a canted spin ferromagnet; the zero-temperature stiffness is linearly related to Tc). Two explanations go beyond it. (1) The essay says the screening is almost negligible because the competing magnetic order 'leaves almost nothing for flux expulsion', and contrasts this with a conventional superconductor that expels all of the field. The paper gives a different reason: for two-dimensional superconductors the screening current is strongly suppressed, and the strength of the Meissner signal is set by the superfluid stiffness together with the sample geometry (it works through a small disc of finite radius as an example). It does not attribute the small signal to magnetic order taking the electrons. (2) The essay says the stiffness 'violates the predictions of BCS theory'. The paper says the temperature dependence is not well fit by an isotropic s-wave superconductor, is well fit by a power law with exponent near 1.9, and could be consistent with an anisotropic gap or distinct gaps on several bands.
Zhang and colleagues (arXiv:2603.25807, March 2026) imaged the Meissner effect in a rhombohedral graphene superconductor by mapping nanotesla-scale fringe fields in real space. They confirmed superconductivity. But the screening was almost negligible — the sample expelled roughly 100 parts per million of the applied magnetic field. A conventional superconductor expels all of it. This one expels almost none.
The superconductor is reluctant because it is also a magnet. Superconductivity in this material emerges during a continuous quantum phase transition into a canted spin ferromagnet. The same electrons that form Cooper pairs for superconductivity are simultaneously developing magnetic order. The two states — one that expels fields, one that generates them — coexist in the same electron system at the same temperature.
The superfluid stiffness — the energy cost of phase fluctuations in the superconducting order parameter — depends on temperature in a way that violates the predictions of BCS theory. In standard superconductors, stiffness drops exponentially near zero temperature as quasiparticle excitations freeze out. Here the drop is not exponential. And the zero-temperature stiffness is linearly proportional to the critical temperature, a relationship seen in cuprate high-temperature superconductors but not in conventional materials.
The material passed the test. It shows the Meissner effect, so it is a superconductor. But it barely passed. The magnetic order competing for the same electrons leaves almost nothing for flux expulsion. The superconducting state exists at the margin of what the definition requires — a phase that is technically present but functionally overwhelmed by its competitor. The measurement had to resolve nanotesla signals to see it at all.
The structural observation: the boundary between superconductor and not-superconductor is not a wall. It is a continuum, and this material sits at the edge — superconducting in principle, barely superconducting in practice, and interesting precisely because the competition between orders leaves the superconductivity almost undetectable.