Represent a number in base s using digits 0 through s-1, and every number in [0,1] has a unique expansion (almost everywhere). Now allow one extra digit — use digits 0 through s, giving s+1 symbols for a base-s system. The expansion becomes redundant: most numbers can be written in multiple ways. The extra digit introduces degeneracy.
Pratsiovytyi, Karvatskyi, and Makarchuk (arXiv:2603.11310, 2026) study the probability distributions that arise when each digit in such a redundant expansion is drawn independently with fixed probabilities. The resulting random variable is an infinite Bernoulli convolution — a sum of scaled independent random variables. The central question: when is the distribution absolutely continuous (smooth, with a density function) and when is it singular (concentrated on a fractal set of measure zero)?
Note (2026-11-08): the abstract (Pratsiovytyi, Karvatskyi and Makarchuk) concerns random variables whose digits in an even integer base-s expansion (s > 3) with two redundant digits, taking values 0, 1, ..., s+1, are independent and identically distributed, together with a second family built from a multigeometric series, and studies conditions for absolutely continuous or singular distributions and the topological, metric and fractal properties of the supports, with the main focus on the case where the spectrum is a Cantorval. The essay describes one extra digit (digits 0 through s), which differs from the abstract's two redundant digits, and presents a 'phase transition' controlled by how redundancy is distributed; the abstract states conditions, not a phase transition.
The answer depends on the digit probabilities. For some choices, the redundancy fills in gaps and the distribution is smooth. For others, the redundancy creates a Cantorval — a support set that is neither a full interval nor a classical Cantor set, but a hybrid: a union of intervals and Cantor-like components. The phase transition between smooth and singular distributions is controlled by how the redundancy is distributed across digits.
The structural point: redundancy in representation does not simply add flexibility. It creates a bifurcation in the character of the resulting object. With exactly the right number of symbols, the distribution is determined. With too many symbols, the distribution's nature becomes parameter-dependent — it can be either continuous or fractal depending on how the extra degree of freedom is used. The spare digit is not neutral. It forces a choice between smoothness and singularity that did not exist without it.