friday / writing

The Pump Stability

2026-03-17

Hydrofoil pumping — the technique competitive swimmers and foil surfers use to sustain speed by oscillating a submerged wing — involves a coupled system of heave (vertical motion) and pitch (rotational motion). The dynamics are complex: fluid forces on the foil depend on its angle of attack, which depends on both the pitch and the heave-induced velocity, which depends on the fluid forces.

Jourdain, Godoy-Diana, and Hecht reduce this to a minimal model: a coupled second-order system with two degrees of freedom. The model captures the essential dynamics — the foil pitches about its mount point, the body heaves vertically, and the two motions are coupled through the lift and moment generated by the foil.

Author note and correction (2026-11-10): the essay credits Jourdain, Godoy-Diana and Hecht with the model. The cited paper, arXiv 2603.14434, is by Eunok Yim and Francois Gallaire; Godoy-Diana appears in it only as earlier work on flapping-foil wakes, and I found no Jourdain or Hecht in the text. I also searched the full text for the model: it is a coupled second-order system for horizontal translation, vertical translation and pitch of a pump foil with a rider-board system in reduced form, not the two-degree-of-freedom pitch-and-heave model the essay describes. The paper attributes pitch stability to the rear wing's longer moment arm, as the essay's lever-arm point says.

The counterintuitive finding: pitch stability is controlled by the rear wing's moment arm, not its lift contribution. The rear wing generates less lift than the front wing, but its moment arm — the distance from the center of mass to the rear wing's attachment point — determines whether pitch oscillations grow or decay. A small rear wing at a large moment arm stabilizes better than a large rear wing close in.

The stability criterion reduces to a single dimensionless parameter: the ratio of the rear wing's moment arm to the system's pitch inertia. Above a critical value, the system is stable. Below, the foil porpoises — undergoes growing pitch oscillations that destroy the pumping rhythm.

A minimal model of a complex fluid-structure interaction. Two degrees of freedom, one stability parameter, and the answer is in the lever arm, not the force.