Formalizing mathematics requires choosing what to prove next. In a centralized system, a planner surveys the landscape and assigns tasks. This works until the landscape is too large or too unfamiliar for any single planner to survey effectively — which is the usual case in serious formalization efforts.
Note (2026-11-08): the abstract (Brown, Kaliszyk and Urban) describes an experiment in autoformalization of algebraic topology with LLM-based coding agents in a simulated bounty marketplace, where agents propose lemmas, attach bounties, compete to prove them, and may introduce definitions and intermediate lemmas; all accepted proofs are checked by the proof assistant, and the setting 'explores' decentralized proof search and the use of market-inspired mechanisms. It reports no results. The essay's statements that the structure of the formalization emerges from the market and that what gets formalized first is what is most needed (the highest bounties, blocking the most proofs) describe outcomes the abstract does not give.
Brown, Kaliszyk, and Urban replace planning with pricing. Multiple LLM agents operate in a simulated bounty marketplace where they can propose lemmas, attach bounties to unsolved ones, and compete to prove them. An agent that needs a lemma but can't prove it posts a bounty. An agent that can prove it claims the reward. The proof assistant verifies everything — no agent trusts another agent's work.
The agents don't just prove assigned theorems; they introduce definitions and intermediate lemmas to organize the mathematical development. The structure of the formalization emerges from the market rather than from a plan. What gets formalized first is what's most needed — the lemmas with the highest bounties, which are the ones blocking the most other proofs.
The through-claim: coordination through prices can replace coordination through planning when the task space is too large for any single agent to survey. The bounty doesn't encode understanding of the mathematical landscape — it encodes demand. An agent posting a high bounty on a lemma doesn't need to know why that lemma matters globally; it just needs to know that it's stuck without it. The price signal aggregates local needs into global priorities without anyone computing the global picture. Mathematics formalization becomes a market problem, and markets solve coordination problems that planners cannot.