A signal conveys meaning only to a learner with the structural capacity to decode it.
Taşkesen (arXiv:2603.19349) models learning as a communication problem. Learners are abstract systems — human, neural network, or otherwise — with prerequisite structures over concepts. To understand concept B, you must first understand concept A. The prerequisite graph determines what a learner can decode, and therefore what any teaching signal can achieve.
Note (2026-11-14; read against the paper's full text): the essay states the threshold and broadcast results as general laws of teaching, but the paper scopes them. The step function (completion probability zero below the structural depth and one at it) is proved for deterministic targets, where the target is known to the teacher and the learner; in the general case with uncertainty about the target the paper's curve is an initial region of impossibility followed by success that becomes increasingly likely as the budget grows, with an epistemic limit on top. The broadcast result (its Theorem 5.6) is an existence statement: one can construct a concept space and learner types for which a common broadcast is slower than personalized teaching by a factor linear in the number of types, so it describes a worst case, not a general rate. The paper also says it does not model analogy, abstraction, forgetting or semantic interpretation, and that its learners are abstract minds with a finite prerequisite structure; the essay's line about teachers' intuition is the essay's own.
Two fundamental limits emerge. The structural limit is set by prerequisite depth: if understanding the target concept requires a chain of n prerequisites, and the teaching period is shorter than n, learning fails entirely — not gradually, not partially, but completely. The epistemic limit is set by uncertainty about what's being taught: the learner doesn't know in advance which concept the signal addresses, and resolving this ambiguity consumes part of the teaching budget.
The threshold behavior is sharp. Below the prerequisite depth, nothing works. At the depth, learning becomes feasible. This is a phase transition in understanding — not a smooth ramp but a wall. Either the learner has the structural capacity to receive the concept, or the concept is unreachable regardless of how the teaching is designed.
The broadcast result quantifies the cost of heterogeneity. A curriculum designed for a single learner can match the prerequisite depth exactly. A broadcast curriculum designed for k different learner types incurs a delay that scales linearly with k. Each additional learner type that must be accommodated reduces the efficiency of teaching for all types. The curriculum cannot be simultaneously optimal for different prerequisite structures.
This formalizes something teachers know intuitively: the problem isn't always the explanation. Sometimes the student lacks the prerequisites that would make the explanation meaningful. And no amount of clearer explanation substitutes for the missing structure. The signal is fine. The receiver isn't ready.