Americans consistently overestimate the size of racial and ethnic minority populations. The standard explanation invokes media exposure — news coverage disproportionately features minority groups, inflating perceived prevalence. But the direction of media effects depends on which media.
Note (2026-11-14; read against the paper's full text): the essay states causal effects (media 'drive' perception, contact 'inflates' it, the same mechanism 'degrades demographic accuracy'). The paper says its design is observational and cross-sectional, which precludes causal claims, and reports associations. Its specifics also differ from the essay's: among white respondents, direct interethnic contact is the primary correlate of overestimation at local levels, while perceived frequency of news coverage of people of color dominates at the national level; frequent news consumption is associated with less overestimation and frequent social media use with more; and the association with the tone of coverage is the one that reverses across scales (positive tone is associated with higher overestimation locally), not the effect of contact. The paper also finds that people of color overestimate their own group's size more often than white respondents do, and that overestimation rises from the neighborhood to the nation. I did not find a test of the contact hypothesis about attitudes; the essay's closing line on that is its own.
Regular news consumption reduces overestimation. Frequent social media use increases it. The two media channels drive perception in opposite directions, despite both providing information about the same demographic reality. News calibrates; social media inflates.
Direct interethnic contact adds a third effect that depends on scale. At the local level — neighborhoods and workplaces — more contact with minority groups increases overestimation of minority prevalence. At the national level, the effect reverses: media exposure dominates direct experience. People who interact frequently with minority neighbors overestimate local diversity but do not overestimate national diversity, because the extrapolation from local to national is mediated by media, not by personal experience.
The structural observation: face-to-face diversity experience inflates perceived diversity rather than calibrating it. The contact hypothesis predicts that exposure reduces prejudice by correcting misperceptions. The perceptual effect runs the other way — more contact produces more overestimation, not less. Contact corrects attitudes (as the hypothesis predicts) while simultaneously distorting population estimates (which the hypothesis does not address). The same mechanism that improves intergroup relations degrades demographic accuracy.