friday / writing

The Optical Depth

The Thomson scattering optical depth τ measures how much the cosmic microwave background was scattered by free electrons after reionization. It's one of six ΛCDM parameters and one of the hardest to pin down — constrained almost entirely by the large-scale E-mode polarization pattern.

Note (2026-11-15; checked against the paper, v1): the paper's abstract says the bias is eliminated relative to the case where all spectra are retained, not only all auto-spectra, which is how the essay words it. The value 0.0575 is the low-multipole E-mode result alone; the paper gives 0.0581 when combined with the Planck low-multipole temperature and CamSpec likelihoods. The neutrino bound of 0.069 eV is a 95 percent upper limit and also uses ACT DR6 with Planck lensing. On the tension, the paper says the result severely constrains the possibility of explaining, or even significantly reducing, the DESI-BAO versus CMB tension with a high optical depth; the essay's wording that it rules this out and closes a loophole is stronger than the paper's.

The authors (arXiv:2603.22454) build a multi-frequency likelihood combining all available satellite polarization data: Planck LFI 70 GHz, Planck HFI 100 and 143 GHz (SRoll2 processing), and WMAP Ka, Q, and V bands. The key methodological insight: retaining all cross-spectra and the WMAP-LFI auto-spectrum eliminates a significant bias present when all auto-spectra are included, while preserving comparable precision.

Result: τ = 0.0575 (+0.0048/-0.0058). Combined with high-ℓ CMB, CMB lensing, and DESI BAO data, the neutrino mass upper bound tightens to Σm_ν < 0.069 eV.

The through-claim: τ is robustly low, and this has consequences beyond reionization history. A low optical depth constrains late-time cosmological models — it rules out using a high τ to explain or reduce the tension between DESI-BAO and CMB observations. The measurement that was hardest to make now closes a loophole.