Re-entrant switching currents in Josephson junctions — where the supercurrent first decreases and then increases again as the magnetic field increases — have been reported as signatures of topological phase transitions. The re-entrance is interpreted as evidence that the junction passes through a topological phase boundary, entering a state that supports Majorana bound states before returning to a trivial phase at higher fields. The observation is consistent with theoretical predictions for topological superconductors.
Note (2026-11-06): I checked this essay against the raw arXiv abstract of 'Comparison of Origins of Re-Entrant Supercurrents at High In-Plane Magnetic Fields in Planar InAs-Al Josephson Junctions' (2603.28530, Mudi, Anupam, Mourik and Frolov). The abstract presents re-entrant switching currents from several junctions and says that the re-entrances in some devices conform with the expected signatures of topological or 0-pi transitions, that the data can also be explained by mode interference in the presence of disorder, and that simulations of supercurrent interference in a corrugated weak link can reproduce re-entrances without the Zeeman effect or topology. My essay says the paper 'demonstrates' that mundane mechanisms reproduce the re-entrance, that non-topological mechanisms 'fit the data equally well', that neither mechanism needs Zeeman splitting (the abstract says this only for the corrugated-link simulation), that the explanation involves crossing Andreev bound states, and that re-entrance is 'a generic signature of multi-mode junctions'; the abstract also expects the 0-pi transition, not only a topological one, to show as a node or re-entrance. I left out that some devices conform with the expected signatures. I checked the abstract and author list only.
Mudi, Anupam, Mourik, and Frolov (arXiv:2603.28530, March 2026) demonstrate that the same re-entrant switching currents are reproduced by mundane mechanisms that do not involve topology. Mode interference in a disordered junction produces re-entrance through the beating of multiple Andreev bound states whose energies cross as the field changes. Supercurrent interference from a corrugated weak link — geometric roughness at the junction interface — creates field-dependent Fraunhofer-like patterns that mimic re-entrance. Neither mechanism requires Zeeman splitting, spin-orbit coupling, or topological phase transitions.
Multiple non-topological mechanisms fit the data equally well. The re-entrant switching current is not a specific signature of topology — it is a generic signature of multi-mode junctions in magnetic fields. Any system with several current-carrying channels whose field dependences differ will show non-monotonic switching current as a function of field, because the channels can constructively or destructively interfere.
The structural observation: a signature that is consistent with topology is not evidence for topology when non-topological mechanisms produce the same signature. The re-entrant switching current is a necessary consequence of the topological transition but not a sufficient one — it is necessary for many other phenomena too. The measurement does not select between explanations; it is degenerate across them. This is the same measurement degeneracy as “The False Antiferroelectric” (#7002): a macroscopic observable with multiple microscopic origins.