Author note (2026-11-02). The paper cited here, arXiv:2603.06124 (“Global Abiotic Sulfur Cycling on Earth-like Terrestrial Planets”), is by Rafael Rianço-Silva, Javed Akhter Mondal, Matthew A. Pasek, Henry Jurney, Marcos Jusino-Maldonado, Henderson James Cleaves. The name(s) this essay attributes it to (Baines) do not appear among the listed authors, so the attribution below is wrong or refers to someone else's earlier work; I have not worked out which. Found by a mechanical check of each essay's named authors against the arXiv author list.
Without life, Earth's sulfur would be in the wrong places.
Sulfur cycles through Earth's surface and interior — volcanoes emit it, oceans dissolve it, sediments bury it. At every step, microbial metabolism rearranges sulfur's oxidation states: sulfate-reducing bacteria pull electrons from organic carbon to reduce sulfate to sulfide, while sulfur-oxidizing bacteria reverse the process. These metabolisms have operated for billions of years, shaping the sulfur distribution we observe.
Baines et al. (arXiv:2603.06124) model the global abiotic sulfur cycle — what happens without any biological sulfur metabolism — and find a planet chemically unlike our own. Marine sediments would contain sulfate concentrations two orders of magnitude higher than Earth's, and sulfide concentrations four orders of magnitude lower. The same element, the same planet, the same geology — but biology has redistributed sulfur so thoroughly that removing it produces a measurably different world.
The model tracks sulfur fluxes through volcanic outgassing, ocean chemistry, sediment burial, and subduction. Without microbial sulfate reduction, the sulfate that enters the ocean from weathering accumulates rather than being reduced. Without sulfur-oxidizing bacteria at hydrothermal vents, the sulfide that enters from volcanism doesn't get recycled back to sulfate. The absence of these metabolisms doesn't leave sulfur unchanged — it leaves sulfur stranded in the wrong oxidation states.
This means sulfur ratios in marine sediments are a potential biosignature. Not the presence of sulfur — which is ubiquitous — but its oxidation-state distribution. A planet with life should have more reduced sulfur in its sediments and less oxidized sulfur than a lifeless planet with identical geology. The signature of life isn't a molecule. It's a ratio.
Baines et al., "Global Abiotic Sulfur Cycling on Earth-like Terrestrial Planets," arXiv:2603.06124 (2026).