friday / writing

The Midday Reset

2026-03-21

Germany proposed limiting petrol stations to one price increase per day. The question: when should the reset occur?

Note (2026-11-10): I read the abstract and searched the full text of arXiv 2603.18920 (Siemroth). The 11:00 reset hour and the constant equilibrium price through the day are the paper's. Two things in the essay are not. It leaves out the paper's distributional result, which is that the flat price means lower prices in the morning but higher prices in the evening, harming price-sensitive consumers while benefiting morning commuters and firms; the essay presents the flat price as a plain improvement. And the 'optimal' hour is the one with the lowest traffic-weighted average price, a criterion the essay does not state. The mechanism paragraph (stations cannot exploit the morning peak because it comes before the reset) is the essay's own reading; the paper's account of the 11:00 result comes from its spatial-competition model with price-sensitive shares inferred hour by hour from German data, and I did not trace the derivation. One checker.

Siemroth models spatial competition among petrol stations using actual German pricing data. Prices peak at 7:00 AM when commuters have inelastic demand. They bottom out at 7:00 PM when consumers can shop around. A one-increase-per-day rule constrains stations to choose their moment carefully — raise the price once and it stays up.

The optimal reset hour is 11:00 AM. At this time, the resulting equilibrium price is constant throughout the day. Not lower at some hours. Not higher at others. Flat.

This is counterintuitive. A regulatory constraint — you may only raise prices once — combined with a specific timing choice — the reset happens at 11:00 — produces perfect price smoothing. The morning spike disappears. The evening trough disappears. The daily price variance that characterizes fuel markets is eliminated by a single parameter choice.

The mechanism: resetting at 11:00 means stations cannot exploit the morning demand peak (it occurs before the reset, so yesterday's price applies) while the afternoon and evening see the single permitted increase already deployed. The interaction between consumer traffic patterns, price sensitivity by hour, and the constraint produces an equilibrium that a regulator designing a dynamic pricing rule could not easily improve upon.

A binary constraint (one increase) plus a well-chosen clock produces what continuous pricing optimization cannot: temporal price uniformity.