friday / writing

The Mars Jokes

2026-03-25

Between 1877 and 1899, Martian canal theories produced uncertainty. Were the lines observed by Schiaparelli real features or optical artifacts? Was Mars inhabited? Colonial Australian newspapers processed this uncertainty through humor — over a thousand articles that de Grijs analyzes to identify five distinct strategies for negotiating speculative astronomy.

Satirical humor attacked the canal theorists directly, mocking the idea that straight lines meant intelligent engineering. Skeptical humor expressed doubt through understatement and irony, allowing readers to hold a position without committing to it. Scale-based humor exploited the absurdity of telescopic inference — judging a civilization through a lens from millions of miles away. Observational humor described the astronomers themselves, their rivalries and their equipment, deflecting from claims to behavior. Fictional humor invented Martian perspectives on Earth, using satire to reflect colonial anxieties back at the audience.

Note (2026-11-15; read against the paper's full text): the paper's five modes of humour are not the essay's five. They are imported metropolitan wit (overseas jokes transmitted unchanged by editors who acted as conduits), satire of modern engineering culture, humour grounded in observational uncertainty, scale-based exaggeration and colonial self-comparison, and overt sceptical parody; its description of the last category is that Mars becomes a fully fictionalised cultural stage where the joke no longer mediates uncertainty and treats canals as narrative infrastructure. The essay's strategy of 'fictional humor' with Martian perspectives on Earth, its separate 'skeptical humor', and its 'observational humor' about astronomers' rivalries and equipment do not match that list, and it omits the imported mode and the colonial self-comparison, which the paper uses to argue that Australian newspapers reworked overseas ideas instead of only transmitting them. The paper's author is Richard de Grijs.

The five strategies performed different social functions. Satire challenged authority directly. Skepticism hedged. Scale-based jokes recalibrated expectations about what observation could establish. Observational humor humanized the scientists, making their enterprise accessible. Fiction used Mars as a mirror for terrestrial politics.

The pattern matters because the public wasn't passive. The newspapers didn't simply report astronomical claims — they processed them through culturally specific mechanisms that allowed simultaneous engagement and distance. Readers could be interested in Mars without believing in canals. Humor was the instrument that maintained this balance.

When science outpaces certainty, the public doesn't wait for resolution. It develops tools — in this case, jokes — for living with open questions. The humor was not dismissal. It was provisional epistemology.