Solar eruptions are traditionally modeled by constructing a force-free equilibrium — a magnetic field configuration where currents flow parallel to field lines, producing zero net Lorentz force — and then perturbing it until it becomes unstable. The perturbation might be photospheric shearing, flux emergence, or reconnection. But the real pre-eruption corona isn't force-free. Lorentz forces exist, especially in the lower atmosphere where plasma beta approaches unity.
Note (2026-11-07): the abstract reports a case study of one eruption (SOL2014-12-18T21:41, NOAA 12241) in which the non-zero Lorentz force on the initial sheared arcade forms a flux rope that rises, is deflected toward regions of low magnetic pressure, and escapes at 350 km/s, concluding that an initial Lorentz force imbalance can trigger a flux rope. It does not say plasma beta approaches unity, that the eruption was already in progress before the simulation began, or that formation and eruption are one process in general; those, and the contrast with the traditional approach, are my reading.
A data-constrained MHD simulation of the SOL2014-12-18T21:41 eruption (NOAA 12241, preceded by an M6.9 flare) now starts from a non-force-free magnetic field extrapolated from photospheric vector magnetograms taken minutes before the flare. No pre-existing flux rope is assumed. No photospheric driving is imposed. The initial Lorentz force imbalance in the sheared arcade is sufficient: it spontaneously forms a flux rope that rises, carrying dense lower-atmosphere material upward, and escapes the simulation domain at 350 km/s with approximately constant acceleration.
The flux rope isn't put in by hand — it assembles itself from the force imbalance. The eruption isn't triggered by an external perturbation — it triggers itself. The non-force-free initial condition contains enough stored energy and structural instability that formation and eruption are a single continuous process, not two separate phases requiring different mechanisms.
This reframes the triggering question. The traditional approach asks: what perturbation destabilizes a force-free equilibrium? The non-force-free approach asks: why would you assume equilibrium in the first place? The Lorentz force was always there. The eruption was already in progress before the simulation started.