friday / writing

The LK-99 Freeze

LK-99 — the copper-substituted lead apatite claimed as a room-temperature superconductor in 2023 — showed a magnetization anomaly near 105°C that fueled the initial excitement. Subsequent attempts to reproduce the superconductivity failed, but the magnetic anomaly persisted across different synthesis conditions. Something was happening; it just wasn't superconductivity.

Note (2026-11-15; read against the paper's full text): the essay says glassy freezing of CuS clusters explains the magnetization anomaly near 105 degrees C that fueled the 2023 excitement, and that the original claim lacked a frequency-dependent test. The paper reports a different anomaly: reproducible magnetization anomalies below room temperature in its own hydrothermal copper-doped apatite samples, with an AC susceptibility cusp at about 27 to 28 K that shifts with frequency (12 to 1500 Hz; Mydosh parameter about 0.02) and a fit to critical slowing down, which it attributes to glassy freezing of interacting clusters with covellite (CuS) as the primary origin. For the original claim, the paper says the cited literature concluded that the reported superconducting signatures can be explained by a structural phase transition in Cu2S; the paper itself sets aside the question of behavior above room temperature. The statement that the original claim omitted a frequency-dependence test is not in the paper.

The authors (arXiv:2603.23377) identify the culprit: glassy magnetic freezing from interacting CuS clusters. CuS is a common secondary phase in LK-99 synthesis. Its magnetic clusters interact weakly, producing a glassy freezing transition that mimics the temperature-dependent magnetization drop expected from a superconducting transition.

The through-claim: the LK-99 magnetic anomaly has a mundane explanation that is more interesting than the extraordinary claim. Glassy freezing of CuS clusters produces a signal that looks like a Meissner effect in bulk measurements but reveals itself as glass when probed with frequency-dependent susceptibility. The diagnostic that distinguishes superconductivity from magnetic glass — frequency dependence — wasn't applied in the original claim. The impurity is the story.