The Page curve describes how entanglement between a black hole and its radiation evolves during evaporation: entropy rises as radiation escapes, reaches a maximum at the “Page time” when the black hole has lost half its degrees of freedom, then falls as the remaining black hole shrinks. Reproducing this curve from microscopic physics was a central achievement of the gravitational entropy program.
Note (2026-11-14; read against the paper's full text): the essay says the rise-peak-fall profile is determined by dimension counting, not by any physical process, and that at zero coupling there is no dynamical mechanism. In the paper the chains still evolve under their own internal transverse-field Ising Hamiltonians (with their own interaction strengths) and the evaporation is implemented by moving the boundary; only the dynamic coupling across the boundary is set to zero. The paper says the internal dynamics play an essential role in the form of the entropy profile, with suppression of entropy growth in certain cases, and that criticality gives a smooth profile while moving away from it distorts the growth and decay. Its claim is for its simulated spin-chain model (matrix product states): shrinking Hilbert-space dimension alone can generate Page curve behaviour. The essay's general statement that the curve is not a signature of gravitational physics goes beyond that.
Two coupled Ising spin chains in a pure bipartite state exhibit the same curve. One chain shrinks while the other grows, mimicking the transfer of degrees of freedom from black hole to radiation. The entanglement entropy traces the Page curve faithfully.
The shock: it persists when the boundary coupling is zero.
At zero coupling between the chains, there is no interaction, no energy transfer, no dynamical mechanism to generate or destroy entanglement. The Page curve appears purely from the shrinking of one subsystem's Hilbert space dimension. As the effective number of degrees of freedom on one side decreases, the accessible entanglement between the two sides first increases (because the growing side has more room to be entangled with the shrinking side) and then decreases (because the shrinking side runs out of states to entangle). The rise-peak-fall profile is kinematic — determined by dimension counting, not by any physical process.
This does not mean the black hole information problem is trivial. The dynamical question — whether information actually escapes and how — remains real. But the Page curve itself, the shape that has driven decades of theoretical effort, turns out to be largely a property of Hilbert space geometry. Any system in which one subsystem loses dimensions while its complement gains them will produce this shape. The curve is not a signature of gravitational physics. It is a signature of shrinking.