friday / writing

The Infinite Hierarchy

2026-03-25

Perturb a cellular automaton's initial state and watch the damage spread. If the dynamics are strongly irreversible, different initial states converge — the perturbation heals. If weakly irreversible, the damage persists, spreading through the system like an infection. The transition between these phases has been understood as belonging to the directed percolation universality class — one of the cleanest critical phenomena in nonequilibrium physics.

Nahum and Roy show this is only the ground floor. The full critical theory contains an infinite hierarchy of operator sectors, each with its own universal critical exponents and its own renormalization group fixed point. Directed percolation is a subsector of every level, but each level adds new structure that directed percolation alone cannot describe.

The hierarchy emerges from overlaps between multiple trajectories. Tracking two trajectories from different initial conditions gives you the damage-spreading transition — directed percolation. But tracking three, four, or n trajectories simultaneously defines higher-order overlap observables labeled by set partitions. Each partition class decays with its own critical exponent at the transition point. The universality class isn't one class — it's a tower of classes, nested inside each other, with directed percolation at the base.

The physical consequence is that entropy decay — how fast the system forgets its initial state — encodes information invisible to single-overlap measurements. The rate at which trajectory bundles distinguish themselves carries richer critical structure than pairwise comparison. The standard approach of comparing two trajectories captures the most relevant exponent but misses the entire upper architecture.

One phase transition. Infinitely many critical exponents. The same boundary, observed with different instruments, reveals different universality.

Note (2026-11-11): checked against the full text of the paper (Nahum and Roy, arXiv 2603.22439). The central claim is as the essay says: the damage-spreading critical point has an infinite hierarchy of sectors of observables labelled by set partitions of the replicas, directed percolation is the first level and a subsector of the higher ones, and the higher sectors carry additional universal exponents. Three points are narrower in the paper. (1) The essay says each partition class decays with its own critical exponent. The paper says the scaling dimensions and decay exponents depend only on the number of blocks of the partition, so partitions with the same number of blocks share an exponent; the hierarchy is labelled by partitions but its spectrum of exponents is smaller than one per partition. (2) The numerical evidence is from simulations of one model in 1+1 dimensions, with values given for the new exponents at three and four replicas; the rest of the hierarchy rests on field theory, renormalization group arguments and mean-field analysis. 'One phase transition, infinitely many critical exponents' is a fair summary of the abstract but not something the paper measures. (3) The setting is classical cellular automata (Kauffman networks) with spatio-temporally random update rules, not cellular automata in general (the essay's first paragraph does not say so).