TOI-561 b is twice the mass of Earth, orbits its star every 10.56 hours at one-fortieth the distance of Mercury from the Sun, and should have lost any atmosphere billions of years ago. The star is twice the age of the Sun. The planet's surface temperature should be nearly 2,700 degrees Celsius. At that proximity and that age, stellar radiation and extreme heating should have stripped every volatile molecule long ago.
Reader note (2026-11-17): The source line cites the Astrophysical Journal Letters paper by Wallack and colleagues; the preprint I matched is arXiv:2509.17231, 'A Thick Volatile Atmosphere on the Ultrahot Super-Earth TOI-561 b' by Teske, Wallack, Piette and colleagues (September 2025, v3 read). Checked against the full text. The finding matches: the dayside is inconsistent with a bare rock and suggests a thick volatile envelope, around a thick-disk star of about 10 Gyr. Figures: the paper's temperatures are in kelvin, with a bare-rock or thin-atmosphere expectation of about 3000 K and fitted brightness temperatures of about 1800 K (plus 130, minus 60) for one reduction, 1870 K for another, and 2150 K for a third fitting of the second; the essay states 1,800 degrees Celsius and 2,700 degrees Celsius, whereas the paper's 1800 K is about 1,500 degrees Celsius, so the units differ (the essay's deficit of about 900 degrees falls within the roughly 850 to 1200 degree gap between the paper's 3000 K and its fitted range). The orbital period of 10.56 hours and the one-fortieth-of-Mercury distance in the essay did not appear in the searches I ran of the paper's text; the paper gives the density as 4.3 +- 0.4 g/cm^3 and an equilibrium temperature of about 2300 K.
The James Webb Space Telescope measured a dayside temperature of 1,800 degrees Celsius — nine hundred degrees cooler than the bare-rock prediction. The deficit is diagnostic: heat is being redistributed from the dayside to the nightside, which requires an atmosphere thick enough to circulate. A bare rock can't move heat. A blanketed rock can.
The planet shouldn't have this atmosphere. It's too small — rocky planets at ultra-short periods are supposed to lose their atmospheres within the first few hundred million years. It's too hot — at these temperatures, most volatile species dissociate or escape. It's too old — the star belongs to the Milky Way's thick disk, an ancient, iron-poor population that formed early in the galaxy's history. Everything about the system says the atmosphere should be gone.
Two possible explanations: the atmosphere is continuously replenished by volcanic outgassing from a magma ocean surface, or the atmosphere's composition is dominated by species that are unexpectedly resistant to escape at these conditions. Either way, the conventional model — that ultra-short-period rocky planets are bare — is wrong for at least this case.
The planet is a survivor. Whatever process is maintaining the atmosphere has been doing so for ten billion years, against conditions that should have stripped it in a fraction of that time. The blanket that shouldn't exist is still there.