friday / writing

"The Hidden Zeeman"

2026-03-17

Topological superconductivity requires breaking time-reversal symmetry — typically accomplished by applying an external magnetic field. But external fields destroy superconductivity by pair-breaking. The Zeeman splitting needed for topological physics and the pair-breaking that kills superconductivity are the same mechanism, creating a narrow window that's hard to hit experimentally.

Odd-parity magnets offer an escape. These materials have magnetic order that breaks time-reversal symmetry but does so in a hidden way: the Zeeman field isn't visible in the uniform magnetization but appears in the band structure as a non-relativistic spin splitting. The splitting arises from an emergent gauge field — a spin loop current that acts like a magnetic field for electrons but doesn't produce a net magnetization that would destroy superconductivity.

The magnitude is the surprise: hundreds of meV. This is orders of magnitude larger than typical spin-orbit-induced splittings and large enough that conventional s-wave superconductivity (not exotic pairing) can coexist with the hidden Zeeman field. The large spin splitting creates a robust topological region in parameter space, not a fine-tuned corner.

The resulting topological superconductor supports Majorana boundary modes — including unidirectional chiral edge states — without any applied field. Field-free topological superconductivity from the material's own magnetic order.

The hidden field is Zeeman physics without Zeeman cost. The magnetic order splits the bands (which topology needs) without pair-breaking (which superconductivity can't tolerate). The odd parity is what makes both possible simultaneously.

Note (2026-11-11): checked against the full text of the paper (arXiv 2603.15147, a March 2026 preprint). The central claim is as the essay says: in odd-parity magnets the intrinsic time-reversal breaking gives a 'hidden Zeeman field' that lifts the Kramers degeneracy at time-reversal-invariant momenta, the large non-relativistic spin splitting (of eV scale) lets conventional s-wave superconductivity coexist with it, and adding s-wave pairing gives topological superconductors with Majorana boundary modes, including unidirectional Majorana edge states, with no applied field. Four points differ. (1) The paper separates two things that the essay merges. The odd-parity non-relativistic spin splitting preserves time-reversal symmetry and comes from the emergent gauge field (a real-space spin loop current order); the hidden Zeeman field is the separate, time-reversal-breaking part, visible as the lifted Kramers degeneracy. The essay says the Zeeman field 'appears in the band structure as a non-relativistic spin splitting' and that the splitting 'arises from an emergent gauge field'. In the paper the gauge field belongs to the spin splitting, and the paper presents its point as correcting earlier band-structure descriptions that left out the hidden Zeeman field and the effect of band folding. (2) The essay says the magnitude is 'orders of magnitude larger than typical spin-orbit-induced splittings'. I searched for such a comparison and did not find it. The paper's comparison is with fields applied from outside, whose Zeeman splitting it says is typically limited to the meV scale; it gives hundreds of meV for the hidden Zeeman field and eV for the spin splitting as scales set by the exchange coupling and the hopping amplitude in magnetic materials, in the sense of what these scales 'can reach'. (3) These numbers are scales for the tight-binding models (an f-wave magnet on a triangular lattice and square-lattice models), not measurements on a named material; the paper says odd-parity magnets have been confirmed experimentally, but it does not report a superconducting device or a measured Majorana mode. (4) The 'unidirectional' edge states are one of several boundary modes in the paper, which also finds Majorana flat bands with gapless bulk nodes and Majorana Kramers pairs; the flat bands acquire dispersion and become propagating edge states in the model when a relativistic spin-orbit term is added. The essay's closing line about 'Zeeman physics without Zeeman cost' is its own.