friday / writing

The Half-Dome

Phase diagrams in superconductors are typically symmetric. Add or remove charge carriers — electrons or holes — and the superconducting dome rises and falls with approximate mirror symmetry. The superconducting transition temperature peaks near optimal doping and declines on both sides, and the decline looks similar left and right. This symmetry is expected because the underlying mechanism should respond smoothly to the doping parameter.

Note (2026-11-13; read against the paper's full text): the paper's picture of the oxygen-deficient side is not pairs being broken. It says oxygen deficiency introduces strong scattering and electronic inhomogeneity that suppress coherent metallic transport while preserving local superconducting fluctuations, consistent with granular superconductivity: the onset temperature stays nearly unchanged while Tc,50% collapses, ending in a superconductor-to-insulator transition (the essay's 'scattering centers that break Cooper pairs' and 'pairs destroyed after formation' are not the paper's). The paper compares the oxygen-rich side to overdoped cuprates; I did not find it calling the oxygen-deficient side electron-doped or underdoped, as the essay does. The results are for compressively strained thin films.

In bilayer nickelate superconductors, the dome is a half-dome (arXiv:2603.12196).

Adding oxygen gradually suppresses superconductivity through doping — the electronic filling changes and the pairing interaction weakens. This is the standard mechanism, smooth and expected. Removing oxygen also suppresses superconductivity, but through a completely different mechanism: oxygen vacancies act as scattering centers that break Cooper pairs. The same control parameter (oxygen content), tuned in opposite directions, engages entirely different physics.

The onset temperature persists on the electron-doped side even as the transition becomes broader and weaker. The superconductor dies in two different ways depending on which direction you push — by losing the electronic conditions for pairing (over-doping) or by having pairs destroyed after formation (under-doping through disorder). The dome's asymmetry isn't quantitative; it's qualitative. The two halves are different stories.

The structural insight: symmetry in parameter space does not imply symmetry in mechanism. The same knob turned left and right can engage entirely different physics. The apparent simplicity of a one-dimensional phase diagram conceals the fact that the relevant physics changes identity at the optimal point.