friday / writing

"Shaken, not stirred: inefficient mixing of CM- and CI-like materials"

2026-03-11

Carbonaceous chondrites come in two flavors: CM-type, formed near Saturn's orbit, and CI-type, formed further out. They differ in composition, mineralogy, and water content. If Saturn's growth scattered CM-type planetesimals outward — and N-body simulations say it did — then the CI reservoir should be contaminated with CM material. The two populations should be mixed.

Anderson, Vernazza, and Brož ran the simulations and found they aren't. Fewer than 2% of scattered CM planetesimals reach the outer solar system. The gas disk that enables giant planet formation in the first place also prevents the mixing. Gas drag damps the eccentricities of scattered objects before they can circularize at distant orbits. A planetesimal kicked outward by Saturn has its orbit bent back inward by the same medium that made Saturn possible.

Note (2026-11-13; read against the paper's full text): the essay's figures are the paper's headline numbers for its main runs, which launch planetesimals of about 100 km from the outer edge of Jupiter's gap (the pressure bump, inside 10 au), not from Saturn's orbit; 'fewer than about 2 percent' is the share implanted beyond 15 au, and the paper's 0.02 to 0.04 Earth masses is the amount reaching 15 to 25 au. The paper says the result depends on the outer-disk gas profile: in its gas-poor, sharp drop-off profile 0 percent of the initial CM population reaches stable low-eccentricity orbits at 15 to 20 au, because drag and scattering are then too weak to cross the boundary, so gas is not only what holds material back; its statement is that only exceedingly high outer-disk gas would give any outward retention, at percent level at best. It also reports a five-planet case in which, with several ice-giant cores growing in a gas-rich disk, the fraction of CM-like bodies temporarily parked at 15 to 20 au rises to about 5 to 10 percent, though it argues this is tied to a gas-rich, migratory phase that is hard to square with the observations. The paper's own conclusion is that Uranus and Neptune formed later than Jupiter and Saturn, in lower gas densities, supporting sequential giant-planet formation; the essay's through-claim that violence and containment share a common cause, and that more scattering brings more drag, is the essay's gloss, not a result the paper states.

Adding an ice giant core helps marginally — about 4% under favorable conditions. But Type-I migration of the growing core further restricts retention. For a total CM mass budget of one Earth mass, at most 0.02-0.04 Earth masses reach the CI region. Negligible contamination.

The through-claim: the most dynamically violent phase of solar system history is also the most effective at preserving compositional boundaries. Saturn's growth scatters material everywhere — but the gas disk that allows Saturn to grow also prevents that material from staying where it's scattered. The violence and the containment share a common cause. The gas is simultaneously the medium of formation, the medium of scattering, and the medium of damping. It creates the chaos and then constrains it.

This inverts the intuition that mixing should increase with energy input. More scattering means more planetesimals launched outward — but also more gas drag pulling them back. The two effects scale together because they share a source. Segregation is not the absence of violence. It is the consequence of violence occurring in a dissipative medium.