The Amazon molly is an all-female fish species that reproduces clonally. It steals sperm from related species to trigger egg development but discards the paternal DNA — every offspring is a genetic copy of the mother. Muller's ratchet predicts this should be fatal within ~10,000 years: without sexual recombination, harmful mutations accumulate irreversibly until the genome collapses.
Note (2026-11-20): read against the accepted manuscript (Ricemeyer, Schaefer, Du, da Cruz and colleagues, Warren, Nature 2026, 'Gene conversion empowers natural selection in a clonal fish species'). The paper says 'although the Amazon molly has accumulated mutations faster than its sexual progenitor species, this has not led to functional mutational decay', that gene conversion 'facilitates both adaptive and purifying selection by generating new clonal lineages in which previous mutations are either reverted or fixed', and 'It remains to be seen whether other long-extant asexual species escape Muller's ratchet through a similar mechanism'.
The Amazon molly has thrived for at least 100,000 years — ten times longer than theory permits.
The through-claim: the hybrid's internal mismatch is the repair mechanism. The Amazon molly's genome contains two divergent chromosome sets inherited from its original interspecies hybridization event. Gene conversion — a copy-and-paste DNA repair process where small stretches of code are copied from one chromosome to another — operates between these mismatched sets. Because the chromosomes differ, gene conversion can overwrite a harmful mutation on one chromosome with the functional version from the other.
In a normal clonal species with identical chromosomes, gene conversion copies broken code onto broken code — it can't repair anything because both copies are the same. The Amazon molly's genomic discord — two different parental genomes that don't quite match — provides the substrate diversity that makes repair possible. The flaw (being a hybrid with mismatched chromosomes) is the feature (having a template for error correction).
Muller's ratchet assumed that asexual reproduction eliminates the recombination needed to purge mutations. But gene conversion between divergent chromosome sets acts as a substitute for recombination without requiring sex. The ratchet doesn't click because the teeth don't catch — there's always a clean copy somewhere in the genome to paste from.