Colloidal gelation is well-understood for spheres. Reduce the repulsion between charged spherical particles and they aggregate into a network — the gel point marks a liquid-to-solid transition with predictable critical dynamics. Rods are different.
Note (2026-11-10): I checked the abstract (both versions agree) of the cellulose nanocrystal gelation paper. It reports a time-connectivity superposition principle with critical dynamics on both sides of the gel point, a boundary between gel and attractive glass states, and a pronounced asymmetry between pre-gel and post-gel dynamics with non-universal values of the dynamic exponent, and it calls for complementary microstructural characterization and theoretical modeling. The essay's explanation that the anisotropy of the rods adds degrees of freedom to the network structure, and its comparison with universal exponents for spheres, are not in the abstract and the authors present the mechanism as open.
Charged cellulose nanocrystals — rigid, rod-shaped colloids — gel through a process with its own superposition principle (arXiv:2603.11366). The evolving viscoelastic data on both sides of the gel point collapse onto master curves when rescaled by a connectivity parameter. Time and connectivity trade off: a system closer to the gel point at a later time looks like a system further from the gel point at an earlier time. The principle is a time-connectivity superposition, analogous to the time-temperature superposition in polymer rheology.
The asymmetry is the surprise. Pre-gel dynamics and post-gel dynamics obey different scaling. The approach to the gel point from the liquid side and the departure from it on the solid side are not mirror images. The dynamic exponent — the rate at which relaxation times diverge near the transition — takes non-universal values that depend on concentration and salt level. The transition is critical, but the critical exponents are not fixed.
For spheres, gelation theory provides universal exponents that depend only on dimensionality. For rods, the anisotropy of the particles introduces additional degrees of freedom into the network structure, and these degrees of freedom show up as non-universal critical dynamics. The shape of the building block changes the rules of the transition.