Why does rule-breaking persist? Traffic violations, tax evasion, legal noncompliance — the penalties exist, the enforcement operates, and yet societies maintain stable rates of disobedience that resist incremental pressure. The standard explanation is insufficient deterrence. The mathematical answer is more interesting: compliance and violation are stable states separated by a phase transition, and the transition type determines whether social order is fragile or robust.
Note (2026-11-10): I checked the abstract (current and first version) and searched the full text of arXiv 2603.10221 (Crokidakis). The two models and their transitions match, and the paper says the bistable regime resembles hysteresis phenomena and a first-order transition. The essay's through-claim, that under positive feedback order is fragile regardless of enforcement level and that the feedback sign and not the enforcement magnitude decides, goes further than the paper. In the paper institutional enforcement, social tolerance and perceived benefits are control parameters whose changes shift the system across the thresholds, and the paper describes small changes in parameters or initial conditions triggering abrupt norm collapse. The essay's statement that recovery needs stronger enforcement than maintenance is its reading of the hysteresis, which the paper mentions only as a resemblance.
Crokidakis builds a replicator dynamics model with three forces: personal incentive to violate, institutional penalty, and peer influence. With positive feedback — where violations become more attractive as more people violate — the system has two stable equilibria: widespread compliance and widespread violation. The transition between them is first-order: abrupt, hysteretic, and resistant to gradual intervention. A society in the compliance state can absorb incremental weakening of enforcement until it hits a tipping point, then collapses discontinuously into widespread violation. And recovering compliance requires stronger enforcement than what was needed to maintain it — the hysteresis means the return path differs from the collapse path.
With negative feedback — where violations become costlier as more people violate — the transition is continuous. Compliance degrades gradually as enforcement weakens, and recovers gradually as enforcement strengthens. No tipping point, no hysteresis, no fragility.
The through-claim: the fragility of social order is not a property of how much enforcement exists but of how violations interact with each other. If one person's rule-breaking makes another's more likely (positive feedback — social acceptance, reduced stigma, overwhelmed enforcement), order is fragile regardless of enforcement level. If one person's rule-breaking makes another's costlier (negative feedback — congestion, collective penalties), order is robust. The feedback sign, not the enforcement magnitude, determines whether a society can collapse.