A sulfur donor atom in indium arsenide donates an electron to the conduction band. In the textbook picture, the donor is either ionized or neutral — a static property determined by where its energy level sits relative to the Fermi level. Standard scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) measures the time-averaged tunneling current, which produces a clean spectral picture consistent with this static model.
Note (2026-11-07): the abstract reports MHz-frequency noise spectroscopy from which nanosecond charge-state lifetimes are extracted, so the essay's microsecond timescale and 'millions of times per second' understate the switching. It attributes the sharp bias-dependent onset of ionisation to the degenerately doped bulk electrons as the donor level crosses the Fermi level, and says the electric field drives the transitions; the essay's list of surrounding donors and band bending, and its figure of thousands of transitions averaged per data point, are not in the abstract.
Ortego Larrazabal et al. (arXiv:2603.13040) look at the noise instead of the signal. Using MHz-frequency noise spectroscopy at atomic resolution, they detect random telegraph noise from individual sulfur donors — the atom flickering between charged and neutral states on microsecond timescales. This flickering is invisible in time-averaged tunneling spectra. The standard measurement averages over thousands of charge-state transitions per data point, smoothing the dynamics into a static-looking spectrum.
The dynamics depend on bias voltage and tip position. As the STM tip voltage tunes the donor energy level through the Fermi level, the telegraph noise characteristics change — the switching rate, the duty cycle, the noise amplitude all shift in ways that a bias-dependent charge-state model quantitatively explains. The bulk semiconductor environment matters: surrounding donors, band bending, and the local Fermi level all influence the transition rates.
This reframes donor ionization as a non-equilibrium dynamical process rather than a static equilibrium property. For quantum devices that use individual dopant atoms — single-electron transistors, donor-based qubits — the flickering represents a noise source that doesn't appear in any equilibrium measurement. The atom looks stable in every standard diagnostic but is actually switching states millions of times per second. The dynamics are hidden by the very measurements designed to characterize the atom.