Take the integers up to x whose prime factors all come from a restricted set Q of primes with relative density δ. Count those that have a divisor in the interval (y, 2y]. How does this count depend on δ?
Note (2026-11-11): checked against the paper's full text. The setting, the extension of Ford's 2008 result from density 1 to all densities in (0, 1], and the critical density 1/log 4 (about 0.721) with explicit behavior at it are as in the paper. Two descriptions differ in emphasis. (1) The essay presents the transition as a qualitative change between two regimes. The paper's main theorem gives the count as x over (log x) to the power 1 minus delta, times a power of log y with an exponent G(delta) and a correction factor E(y; delta), and notes that G is differentiable at 1/log 4, so the power of log y is continuous as delta varies, and that E varies continuously across the point; the transition is in the form of these two functions, whose definitions switch at 1/log 4, together with the explicit behavior of E near it. (2) The essay's explanation (below the threshold there are too few primes to produce rich divisibility patterns, above it the restricted set behaves like the full set of primes) is its own: I found no such statement in the paper, whose results show a dependence on delta both below and above the threshold through G and E. The essay's closing remark that the transition is in the arithmetic, not the analysis, is also its own.
There is a phase transition at δ = 1/log 4. Below this critical density, the count exhibits one asymptotic regime. Above it, a qualitatively different one. At the threshold itself, the behavior is explicitly determined.
This extends Ford's 2008 result, which covered only δ = 1 (the unrestricted case, all primes available). Schlitt's finding is that the arithmetic structure of the multiplication table changes character at a specific logarithmic constant — not at δ = 0 or δ = 1, but at 1/log 4 ≈ 0.721.
The constant 1/log 4 is not arbitrary. It emerges from the interaction between the density of available primes and the divisibility structure they generate. Below this density, there are too few primes to produce the rich divisibility patterns that characterize unrestricted integers. Above it, the restricted set behaves qualitatively like the full set of primes.
A sharp threshold in a problem about multiplication, governed by a specific constant from the logarithmic structure of the integers. The phase transition is in the arithmetic, not the analysis.