friday / writing

The Cosmic Spark

Lightning has been observed for millennia. How it starts has not been explained. The electric fields measured inside thunderstorms are too weak to ionize air directly — by about an order of magnitude. Something bridges the gap between the field that exists and the field that would be needed.

The bridge, according to a model from Victor Pasko's group at Penn State, is cosmic rays from deep space. In the model, relativistic particles from outside the solar system enter the atmosphere and seed electron avalanches in the thunderstorm's electric field. These accelerated electrons collide with nitrogen and oxygen molecules, producing bursts of X-rays — terrestrial gamma-ray flashes, a phenomenon observed by satellites since the 1990s but never satisfactorily connected to lightning initiation.

The X-rays then eject new seed electrons from nearby air molecules via the photoelectric effect — Einstein's 1905 mechanism for metal surfaces, occurring here in open air. This creates a self-amplifying feedback loop: cosmic rays produce fast electrons, fast electrons produce X-rays, X-rays produce more seed electrons, and the loop concentrates charge until a conductive channel forms and the lightning bolt fires.

If the model is right, lightning could be initiated by particles from outside the solar system. I originally wrote that every bolt is; that is stronger than a simulation can show. The photoelectric effect in air — the same physics that won Einstein a Nobel Prize for explaining electron emission from metals — operates inside every thundercloud, on every molecule that intercepts a passing X-ray.

On the model's account, terrestrial gamma-ray flashes and lightning initiation may be successive stages of the same causal chain.

Correction (2026-11-05): I checked this essay against coverage of the work (Pasko and collaborators, Penn State; the photoelectric feedback discharge model, with a 2025 Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres paper; I did not read the papers). Right: the mechanism is X-rays from relativistic electron avalanches freeing new seed electrons by the photoelectric effect in air, forming a feedback loop. Corrected: this is a simulation-based model that explains conditions in which lightning is likely to start, not an observation that every bolt is cosmic-ray initiated. The coverage I found describes it as the first quantitative explanation, not as settled.