Outer solar system bodies — comets, Kuiper Belt objects, the icy moons — contain more CO relative to water than models of the mature protoplanetary disk predict. The standard disk model starts with a fully formed disk and evolves the chemistry: CO and water freeze out at their respective snowlines, pebbles drift inward, and the volatile budget is set by the equilibrium between freezing, sublimation, and transport. This predicts a CO/H₂O ratio that is too low to match observations.
Note (2026-11-15; read against the paper's full text): The paper's results are more qualified than the essay's. It finds that CO-rich pebbles form at the CO snow line through the cold finger effect whether or not the disk buildup stage is included; including buildup gives a stronger CO enhancement relative to water in the outer disk. It also finds that CO-rich planetesimals do not form in its smooth disk models, and says forming them likely needs mechanisms that preserve the CO-enriched ice, such as pressure traps or gas removal. So the essay's lines that the disk formation stage is where the enrichment happens, that omitting it 'erases the explanation', and that the enrichment is 'already complete and frozen into the solid material' go beyond the paper, as does the description of pebbles carrying the CO outward (in the paper the pebbles drift inward and the vapour, flowing outward with the gas, refreezes outside the snow line).
Drążkowska (arXiv:2603.26876, March 2026) shows that including the disk buildup stage — the period when the disk is still forming from infalling cloud material — qualitatively changes the predicted volatile budget. During buildup, dust grains grow and begin drifting inward before the disk reaches steady state. The CO snowline acts as a cold finger: CO vapor from the inner disk diffuses outward and refreezes on drifting pebbles at the snowline. The pebbles carry this excess CO ice outward as they continue to grow and are incorporated into planetesimals.
The cold finger effect is a one-way pump. CO sublimates as pebbles drift inward past the snowline, diffuses as vapor, and refreezes on outward-facing pebble surfaces. The pebbles carry more CO ice than the local gas composition would predict because they accumulated it during their passage through the snowline region. The enrichment depends on the disk being actively built — in a mature disk at steady state, the cold finger saturates and the enrichment disappears.
The structural observation: the simplification of assuming a pre-formed disk — a standard starting condition in planet formation models — was suppressing a real chemical enrichment mechanism. The disk's formation phase is not merely a prelude to the interesting chemistry; it is when the interesting chemistry happens. By the time the disk reaches the steady state that models typically use as an initial condition, the volatile enrichment is already complete and frozen into the solid material. Starting the model too late erases the explanation.