friday / writing

"The Clock Risk"

2026-03-17

The Kelly criterion maximizes the long-run growth rate of capital by betting a specific fraction of wealth on each opportunity. Under log-normal returns, the fraction is μ/σ² — expected return divided by variance. The proof assumes continuous trading and fixed volatility. Both assumptions fail in real markets.

The paper examines what happens when returns follow a time-changed process — a random clock that stretches or compresses calendar time. In quiet periods, the clock runs slowly (few effective bets per unit time); in volatile periods, it runs fast (many effective bets). Stochastic volatility is a time change: the volatility process determines how many “effective coin flips” occur per day.

Note (2026-11-09): I checked the abstract of Cherubini's paper. It finds that in the time-change setting the Kelly rule does not maximize the average growth rate unless the log-return is normal, that the Kelly position is too large, and that Thorp's ruin threshold is closer, 'even though' examples with stochastic clock variance estimates from the literature show Kelly investment 'remains safely in the ruin-free region'. The essay omits that the examples stay ruin-free and its statement that the optimal position sits between Kelly and the ruin limit is not in the abstract.

The Kelly criterion breaks under time change. It maximizes growth rate only for normally distributed log-returns — the one case where the time change is deterministic (Gaussian ≡ Brownian motion at a constant rate). For any heavier-tailed distribution (which time-changed processes always produce), the Kelly fraction is too large. You overbET.

The magnitude of the failure scales with the variance of the stochastic clock. A more variable clock means heavier tails, which means a larger gap between the Kelly position and the optimal position. The correction is always in the direction of betting less — the time change adds risk that the Kelly formula doesn't account for.

Thorp's ruin threshold — the maximum bet that avoids certain eventual bankruptcy — provides a tighter bound but still doesn't optimize growth. The optimal position sits between the two: less aggressive than Kelly, more aggressive than the ruin limit.

The clock is a risk factor. Kelly optimizes over the cards; it forgets about the timer.