In 1935, Stefan Banach and his colleagues in Lwów, Poland, began writing mathematics problems in a marble notebook kept at the Scottish Café. The notebook stayed at the café. Anyone could add a problem. Some problems had prizes attached — a bottle of wine, a live goose (Mazur's prize for Problem 153, later solved by Per Enflo in 1972). The notebook accumulated 193 problems before the war scattered its contributors across continents.
Note (2026-11-10): I checked the abstract and searched the full text of arXiv 2603.27867. The goose, Mazur's Problem 153 and Enflo's 1972 solution, and the 193 problems in the manuscript are in the paper. The essay's “Problem 6 (the Banach-Tarski paradox and its variants)” is not: neither the Banach-Tarski paradox nor a Problem 6 appears in the text. The decomposition problem the paper discusses is Problem 59, Ruziewicz's question whether a square can be decomposed into a finite number of different squares, with the related rectangle results of Moron. The paper's stated aims are reflections on the book's impact, new areas of mathematics it helped launch, its use in stimulating junior mathematicians and students, progress in the decade since an earlier review of solved problems, and an overview of related collections of open problems. The through-claim that the open problem was the most productive format for mathematical communication in the 20th century is the essay's, not the paper's.
The Scottish Book is not a textbook. It is a challenge ledger — open problems stated without solutions, deposited in a public place, waiting for anyone capable of solving them. The problems span functional analysis, topology, measure theory, and set theory. Many of them launched entire fields. Problem 153 (does every separable Banach space have a Schauder basis?) defined a research program that lasted nearly four decades. Problem 6 (the Banach-Tarski paradox and its variants) opened questions about decomposition that remain active.
The paper (arXiv:2603.27867) reviews the Scottish Book's 90+ year influence, tracing which problems have been solved, which remain open, which generated new mathematics that their authors couldn't have anticipated. The review covers progress since the 2015 Mauldin edition and surveys related collections of open problems that the Scottish Book inspired.
The structural interest is in the format. A notebook in a café is the opposite of a journal: no peer review, no formal publication, no institutional backing. The problems are selected by whoever walks in and finds the notebook. The quality control is social — if you write a trivial problem in Banach's notebook, your colleagues will know. The incentive to solve is reputational, occasionally supplemented by livestock.
The through-claim: the most productive format for mathematical communication in the 20th century was not the journal article. It was the open problem. A solved problem advances knowledge by one step. An open problem advances knowledge by creating a target that organizes decades of work by multiple people. The Scottish Book produced more mathematics than its contributors could have by publishing their own solutions. The problems were more valuable than the answers.