Wave-particle duality enforces a complementarity relation: path distinguishability and interference visibility cannot both be maximal simultaneously. The more precisely a photon's path is known, the less coherence its interference pattern shows. This tradeoff is quantified by a linear inequality, D² + V² ≤ 1, that has held across every experimental configuration tested since Bohr.
Note (2026-11-11): checked against the full text of the paper (Siddiqui, Qutubuddin and Qureshi, arXiv 2603.27780). The central result is as the essay says: in the quantum switch the standard spatial duality relation can be saturated while the causal coherence (the coherence of the reduced order qubit) is simultaneously maximal, which rules out a universal, state-independent, linear additive relation among the three quantities. Three things in the essay differ. (1) The essay says the standard complementarity relation 'breaks down'. In the paper the standard duality relation still holds and is saturated; tracing out the order qubit recovers it, and what is excluded is a joint linear relation including causal coherence. (2) The essay says D squared plus V squared at most 1 has held 'across every experimental configuration tested since Bohr'; the paper's discussion uses a linear relation (C plus D_Q at most 1, for a fixed causal order), mentions quadratic Englert-type relations only as a separate case, and does not make that claim about experiments. (3) The essay leaves out the paper's positive result: that complementarity does admit a state-dependent entropic uncertainty formulation based on incompatible measurements on the causal degree of freedom. The paper's wording of its conclusion is that operational formulations of complementarity can depend on causal structure; the essay's 'not a fundamental law' is stronger than that.
When causal order is itself placed in quantum superposition — using the quantum switch, where the order of two operations is coherently controlled — the standard complementarity relation breaks down. No universal linear relation exists that simultaneously captures path distinguishability, spatial coherence, and causal coherence.
The specific violation: spatial duality (the standard wave-particle tradeoff) and causal coherence (the quantum superposition of temporal orderings) can both be simultaneously maximal. In the standard framework, any form of coherence should trade off against any form of distinguishability. With indefinite causal order, the trading space has more dimensions than the standard inequality accounts for, and the additional dimension — causal coherence — is not constrained by the spatial tradeoff.
The structural observation: complementarity is a consequence of definite causal structure, not a fundamental law. When causal structure becomes quantum, the tradeoff that complementarity enforces acquires additional degrees of freedom that the original inequality does not constrain. The bound D² + V² ≤ 1 remains valid for each definite causal order individually, but the superposition of causal orders allows the system to simultaneously saturate tradeoffs that are mutually exclusive within any single causal order.