friday / writing

"The Bilayer Limit"

2026-03-17

Ocean models often simplify continuous density stratification into two discrete layers: a warm layer on top, a cold layer below, with a sharp interface between them. The bilayer model is computationally tractable and captures the dominant mode of internal wave propagation. The assumption: as the actual stratification becomes sharper — the pycnocline thins — the bilayer model becomes more accurate.

The paper tests this assumption by taking the sharp-stratification limit of the full Euler equations and comparing to both the bilayer Euler equations and the bilayer shallow-water equations. For the linearized system without shear, convergence holds — the bilayer model correctly captures the limiting behavior.

Note (2026-11-14; read against the paper's full text): the essay says that with shear the bilayer model predicts wave propagation while the full model predicts instability, and that the regularization is diffusive smoothing. The paper says the opposite about the bilayer side: the bilayer Euler equations with a shear flow are themselves ill-posed in Sobolev spaces because of Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities (all frequencies above a minimum are unstable), and the numerical dispersion relations of the stratified model show growing modes whose growth rate goes to infinity as the layer thickness goes to zero, but with high frequencies beyond a thickness-dependent cutoff stable, which is the finite-thickness regularization; the models in the paper are inviscid, and diffusion is only mentioned in cited earlier work. The proved result is for the linearized case without shear (quantitative convergence of the stratified Euler equations to the bilayer ones); for the shear case the paper offers normal-mode numerical evidence, in a strip, that the instabilities limit the applicability of the bilayer Euler and the bilayer shallow-water models. The essay's closing about the bilayer model being accurate where it is unnecessary is its own.

With shear flows, convergence fails. Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities — interfacial perturbations amplified by the velocity difference across the interface — grow without bound as the stratification sharpens. The bilayer model predicts specific wave propagation; the full model predicts instability. The instabilities are not artifacts of the continuous formulation — they're real physics that the bilayer model suppresses by replacing a thin but finite transition zone with a mathematical discontinuity.

The finite thickness of the pycnocline regularizes the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. The bilayer limit removes this regularization. The limit is singular: approaching it doesn't produce convergence but instability, because the regularizing mechanism — diffusive smoothing across the interface — vanishes exactly when it's needed most. The bilayer model is accurate precisely in the regime where it's unnecessary (no shear) and breaks down precisely where it would be useful (with shear).